Saturday, January 07, 2006

WARNING: Extreme Geek Post



I bought a new calculator for the first time in ages. Like all really cool people, I prefer HP Reverse Polish Notation (RPN) calculators. I bought the 33s. There aren't many options—RPN is fast going the way of the manual transmission. (Although, naturally, my orange car has a stick.)

Mostly I am pleased, but I do have five complaints.

1) You can actually operate it in algebraic mode—using the ENTER key as an equals sign. Blasphemy!

2) Made in China. Sigh.

3) The left/right function keys are teal and purple. What were they thinking?

4) It doesn't have that indestructible feeling of the old HPs.

5) The ENTER button should be double-sized.

It is still great geek-fun to hand someone requesting a calculator an HP RPN type and watch them struggle to locate the '=' button. Heh. It makes me smile just thinking about it!

Thursday, January 05, 2006

Dover Judge Declares: String Theory Illegal!

Not.

But still, you have to wonder. After all, I am fairly certain Judge Jones would not have been sympathetic to, say, Michael Behe arguing:
"It would be very foolish to throw away the right answer on the basis that it doesn't conform to some criteria for what is or isn't science."
That would have been about as well received as a PZ Myers commencement address at Bob Jones University.

In truth, nobody would dare use that as justification for ID.

It is, however, being used in high energy physics. Prominent scientists are asking the community to accept their String Theory work even though it doesn’t conform to what we have traditionally (and now judicially) defined as the standard for science.

In a January 4, 2006 online article on Nature (subscription required) entiled Our Universe: Outrageous Fortune, correspondent Geoff Brumfiel writes:


For two decades now, theorists in the think-big field of cosmology have been stymied by a mathematical quirk in their equations. If the number [the cosmological constant] controlling the growth of the Universe since the Big Bang is just slightly too high, the Universe expands so rapidly that protons and neutrons never come close enough to bond into atoms. If it is just ever-so-slightly too small, it never expands enough, and everything remains too hot for even a single nucleus to form. Similar problems afflict the observed masses of elementary particles and the strengths of fundamental forces.

In other words, if you believe the equations of the world's leading cosmologists, the probability that the Universe would turn out this way by chance are infinitesimal - one in a very large number. "It's like you're throwing darts, and the bullseye is just one part in 10120 of the dart board," says Leonard Susskind, a string theorist based at Stanford University in California. "It's just stupid."

Amazingly a growing number of physicists are abandoning hope of finding an explanation in the form of a falsifiable, predictive (i.e., scientific) theory and are instead accepting the following explanation: dumb luck. Oh, to be sure, it's dumb luck mitigated by gazillions of unseen, unlucky universes behind the curtain (don't peek)—but it’s dumb luck just the same. Brumfiel writes:


But things have changed in the past few years, says astronomer Bernard Carr of Queen Mary, University of London, UK. String theorists and cosmologists are increasingly turning to dumb luck as an explanation. If their ideas stand up, it would mean the constants of nature are meaningless. "In the past, many people were almost violently opposed to that idea because it wasn't seen as proper science," Carr says. "But there's been a change of attitude."

Susskind, according to Brumfiel, tells us that things are not as bad as they sound—as long as you possess faith, or the belief in what is not seen:


More recently, string theorists have calculated that there could be 10500 universes, which is more than the number of atoms in our observable Universe†. Under these circumstances, it becomes more reasonable to assume that several would turn out like ours. It's like getting zillions and zillions of darts to throw at the dart board, Susskind says. "Surely, a large number of them are going to wind up in the target zone." And of course, we exist in our particular Universe because we couldn't exist anywhere else.

Brumfiel reports that Nobel Laureate and director of the prestigious Kavli Institute for Theoretical Physics at UCSB, David Gross, who is a more traditional scientist—that is one who still believes in what we used to call science, is less than impressed:


It's an intriguing idea with just one problem, says Gross: "It's impossible to disprove." Because our Universe is, almost by definition, everything we can observe, there are no apparent measurements that would confirm whether we exist within a cosmic landscape of multiple universes, or if ours is the only one. And because we can't falsify the idea, Gross says, it isn't science. Or at least, it isn't science in any conventional sense of the word. "I think Gross sees this as science taking on some of the traits of religion," says [Bernard] Carr. "In a sense he's correct, because things like faith and beauty are becoming a component of the discussion."

A criticism that the theory is impossible to disprove—does that sound familiar?

According to Benard Carr, then, Gross sees the megaverse of the String Theory landscape, which is gaining wider and wider acceptance in that juicy intersection of cosmology and high energy physics, as religion.

A criticism that the theory amounts to religion—does that sound familiar?

Interestingly enough, a way, we are told, to look for evidence supporting design the landscape megaverse is to search for even more fine-tuning beyond the well-known cosmological constant miracle. The reasoning is straightforward:
  1. Our universe is fine-tuned.

  2. The only “scientific” (pay no attention to Professor Gross gnashing his teeth) explanation is a String Theory landscape megaverse.

  3. Therefore, discovering even more fine-tuning provides (indirect) support for the megaverse!
If you think I’m kidding, read more from Brumfiel's Nature article, especially the last paragraph quoted below:

In 2007, researchers at Europe's CERN particle physics centre in Geneva, Switzerland, will turn on the Large Hadron Collider, a massive accelerator that will probe particle energies never before seen by researchers. The accelerator might detect so-called supersymmetric particles, predicted by some as a way of unifying the strong and weak nuclear forces with the electromagnetic force, an important step in uniting all the forces of physics within a single theory.

These particles could also hint at whether we live in one of many universes, says Nima Arkani-Hamed, a string theorist at Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts. If the collider detects certain types of super-symmetric particles, he says, it will indicate another fine-tuning in the cosmos — the ratio of the weak nuclear force to the strength of gravity. The anthropic argument is the same: if the number was off by as little as one part in 1030, then we would not be here to discuss it.

It might seem that the detection of a second, perfectly tuned number would only exacerbate the debate, but Arkani-Hamed argues that it will have the opposite effect. Unlike the cosmological constant, which has had a controversial history even in cosmology, this fine-tuning would appear in the standard model, which most physicists consider to be the most complete physical theory ever developed and tested. It would strengthen the case for the arbitrary nature of certain fundamental constants, Arkani-Hamed contends: "These measurements wouldn't directly prove or disprove the landscape, but they would be a very big push in that direction."

The last sentence is quite amazing. Detection of a new, thirtieth decimal fine-tuning won’t directly prove the landscape, but it would be a big push in that direction! Why? Because there is no other explanation of course, other than, well—design, and that’s not science!

We live in a crazy world. Oh, for the good old days when a new example of fine-tuning was considered a definite win for the ID camp. Now everybody wants the universe to be fine-tuned! This is a sort of unforeseen grand unification. We’ll all share something meaningful: the more fine-tuning we uncover, the more we all will have faith in whatever undetectable force we believe is behind it all. It’s a little disturbing. Maybe more than a little.

Susskind, when not writing popularized books on the subject, is apparently concerned. Brumfiel tells us:


Susskind, too, finds it "deeply, deeply troubling" that there's no way to test the principle. But he is not yet ready to rule it out completely. "It would be very foolish to throw away the right answer on the basis that it doesn't conform to some criteria for what is or isn't science," he says.

If I substituted “Behe” for Susskind” in the quote above, you’d probably think he was talking about irreducible complexity. And if Behe actually made such a statement, he’d be lampooned in all the usual places. The community is somewhat kinder to Dr. Susskind.

I have always said ID is not science. I think it is now defensible to say it differently: ID is as much science as String Theory is.


† Stating that 10500 is bigger than the number of atoms in the observable universe is even more drastic than the Innumeracy example of saying "McDonalds has sold more than one hamburger." The actual number of atoms in the observable universe is ~1082.

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

Bats are Birds?

Whenever you make the claim that the Bible and science are compatible, naysayers will bring-up a series of claims which purport to prove otherwise. These are often presented in a show-stopper manner, as if they have uncovered problematic scripture that no biblical scholar knew existed. So confident are they that any reasonable person would immediately concede the correctness of their view, they don’t actually make an argument—they simply quote a passage, cross their arms and sneer. (Okay, over the internet it only smells like they are crossing their arms and sneering.)

This is the first of a series of posts that I want to use to rebut the oh-so-common points that they reinvent every time this topic arises.

As an introduction, I want to say that it would be a total and utter disaster if the Bible said anything that was inconsistent with (true) science. By “true” science I mean science that has been confirmed beyond any reasonable doubt. For example, if the bible taught that the earth was at the center of the cosmos—that would be a disaster. For if the Bible is in error in any statement, it might be in error in its gospel message—and that would make us the most miserable of creatures.

When reconciling these alleged scientific errors—we need to do a credible job. However, we do not have to play by the ground rules of our critics. Their ground rules are this: you must take the passage hyper-literally; purely at face value. You are not allowed to use arguments like “figure of speech” or “hyperbole” or “translation error” or “let’s place it in context.”

On the other hand, we must be honest. If we are to argue that a passage should not be taken hyper-literally, we need to have justification for reading it in the manner that resolves the supposed problem. If the explanation is a translation error, we need to provide evidence.

Oh, by the way, miracles don’t count. They, by definition, are inconsistent with science—otherwise they would be called parlor tricks. We do not have to explain how Moses parted the Red Sea or how Jesus walked on water to reconcile the Bible with science. The fact that science cannot explain miracles is a feature, not a bug.

So let’s, one by one, look at those passages that “prove” the Bible is not consistent with science.

Bats are Birds

The first one we will examine comes from the book of Deuteronomy (A similar passage is in Leviticus):
11 “You may eat all clean birds. 12 But these are the ones that you shall not eat: the eagle, the bearded vulture, the black vulture, 13 the kite, the falcon of any kind; 14 every raven of any kind; 15 the ostrich, the nighthawk, the sea gull, the hawk of any kind; 16 the little owl and the short-eared owl, the barn owl 17 and the tawny owl, the carrion vulture and the cormorant, 18 the stork, the heron of any kind; the hoopoe and the bat. (Deuteronomy 14:11-18)
The problem is clear enough. The Bible states bats are birds, when every grade-schooler knows that bats are mammals.

There are a number of ways to address this claim.

The ancients were not stupid

This is not so much an argument against the details of the claim, but a comment regarding the foolishness of making it in the first place. In fact, this point can be made regarding most if not all of the assertions of biblical scientific error: There is an assumption behind these claims that the ancients were idiots—and their ignorance was written into the Bible, belying both the inspiration and inerrancy (and hence the authority) of scripture.

If one were to make a more logical assumption, namely that the ancients were not morons, then one would be inclined, before declaring victory, to ask whether or not the offending statements could in some manner be correct. This could be done without acknowledging that the Bible is truth rather than fiction. It’s a simple matter of prudent caution; the realization that maybe they did know what they are talking about.

Taxonomy is not Fundamental Science

Classification schema are not written into the fabric of the universe. In fact, taxonomy debates are fairly common. Taxonomy is something we overlay on the diversity of life. It is done sensibly, but there is not an ultimate taxonomy that we have either discovered or awaits discovery. There is only the question of what is useful, self-consistent, and comprehensive enough for present scientific needs.

One rebuttal of the argument that the Bible errs is stating that bats are birds is that, in the simpler taxonomy of the ancients, bats were simply classified as birds. They were under no obligation to adhere to twenty-first century taxonomy—a taxonomy that itself may someday be completely revamped. (And if that happens, it would not relegate the current scheme into the dustbin of scientific error.)

A taxonomy, for example, that has four broad categories: sea life, amphibians, land animals, and flying-things (lets call them birds) is not incorrect and is not scientific error. It’s just not the scheme we use today.

Translation Weakness

A additional but not unrelated explanation is not so much translation error but translation weakness. The Hebrew word ôwph, translated as “birds” or “fowl” means winged. Thus a better translation might be: “You may eat all clean winged animals...” or “You may eat all clean flying things...” It was not grossly wrong, however, to choose “birds.”

Furthermore, even the word atallêph, translated as “bat” is done so with less than absolute certainty—it may mean “an animal flying in the dark.” Footnotes in many bibles attest to the uncertainty of translating atallêph as “bat.” So it is possible, though not critical for this argument, that “bats” is a mistranslation.

Summary

The bottom line remains that, independent of the fairly strong case for translational looseness, we have the argument that the ancients were entitled to their own classification scheme, one that met their needs, and without question a scheme that groups bats and birds together is entirely sensible. To reiterate: our modern classification scheme is not fundamental science. It is not like “general relativity.” A disagreement with our scheme in no way constitutes a scientific error.

Lesson 3: Deity of Christ (Part 2)


(This is based on John Gerstner’s Primer on the Deity of Christ from a compilation of his primers in the book Primitive Theology. I am using Primitive Theology for my Sunday School class. There is a growing list of links on the left for the posts for this class.

Proof of Jesus’ Deity from the Sermon on the Mount

Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount, as found in Matthew 5-7, is not usually offered up as proof of His divinity. But upon closer inspection, it is. Consider the Beatitudes. Here Jesus utters some of His most well known statements, such as “Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven.” “Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God.” And so on.

These statements are often used as further evidence for Jesus’ love, His kindness, and His moral teaching. But do they not say more if we think about how they are stated? They are stated with absolute and final authority. Jesus is not citing any other authority upon whom one can trust his teaching on whom will inherit the kingdom of God—he invokes only his own.

Looked at it differently, Jesus could be just a good teacher. Or He could be a prophet. Or He could be God.

If Jesus recognized himself as merely a good teacher, he would have stated something like: “My beloved, I believe that the poor in spirit are blessed and I believe that theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven.”

If Jesus were a prophet, he would have stated something like: “Thus saith the Lord: Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven.”

A mere teacher would qualify his teachings, as self-evident as they may be, as his own beliefs—and would offer scriptural support. A prophet would acknowledge that the source of the teachings is something beyond himself, namely God. Only God would rationally make these pronouncements as absolute fact on basis of the authority of the speaker. When, as Christians, we read the beatitudes we instinctively understand that God is speaking. But we rarely flesh that out to its logical conclusion: Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount testifies to His divinity.

This is most evident in the last beatitude. Here Jesus states: “Blessed are you when men shall revile you and say all manner of evil against you falsely for My sake. Rejoice and be exceeding glad for so persecuted they the prophets that were before you.”

Here we have a clear claim of divinity, should we care to look for it. For this says more than you will be persecuted, and the prophets were persecuted too. It attests that the prophets and the disciples were/will be persecuted for the same reason: for the sake of Jesus. No human being could claim that the prophets of hundreds of years earlier had been persecuted for his sake. Only a pre-existing entity could make such a claim—only God could make the claim.

Jesus’ Comments on the Bible Attest to His Divinity

Recall when Jesus teaches us how hard it is to be a Christian. He does this when pointing out misconceptions about Old Testament scripture. He says: “It is said by them of old time, ‘Thou shalt not kill,’ but I say unto you…” or “It is said by them of old time, ‘Thou shalt not commit adultery,’ but I say unto you…”

We need to consider the magnitude of these statements. Jesus is speaking to an audience that (rightly) considered the Old Testament as the inspired word of God. Jesus calmly recites the Old Testament passages, and then proceeds to make statements that supersede them. He matter-of-factly and clearly places his pronouncements on the same level as Holy Scripture. Only God can do this. Once again, imagine the absurdity of even the apostle Paul stating “scripture says this, but what I say is…”

Notice that the way Jesus makes these claims cannot rest on his sinlessness alone. If Jesus were sinless but not God (if such a thing were possible)—that is if he were merely a man who had reached the theoretical limit of human perfection—the statements of his which we have been discussing would still be blasphemous. And by making such statements, he would no longer be sinless!

The Most Definitive Statement of Jesus’ Divinity from the Sermon on the Mount

At the end of His sermon, Jesus describes a frightening scene of judgment, when Jesus tells us: “In that day men shall come before Me and say, ‘Lord, Lord. Have we not prophesized in thy name? Have we not cast out demons in thy name? Have we not done mighty works in thy name?’ And I shall say unto them, ‘Depart from me ye workers of iniquity, I never knew you.’ ”

Jesus’ teaching of His own divinity could hardly be clearer. He describes being called Lord, and He takes no steps to correct it as an error, so we assume he accepts the honorific. But more importantly, He places himself as ruler over the final judgment of man—a role that belongs only to God.

Why does Jesus never say “I am God?” Perhaps it is because He says it so clearly and in ways that provide more details. The statement we have just discussed is just as clear in its claim of deity, yet it teaches us much more than a simple declarative statement.

To be continued...

Tuesday, January 03, 2006

New book—should I or shouldn’t I?

I am thinking about writing another book—this time non-fiction. In fact, I have already written a couple chapters.

I want to write on the science-faith interface, but I don’t want to jump into what is already a crowded field. The world does not need another book on fine-tuning. There are at least twenty of them out there.

It seems to me that what may generate interest and provide some value is a book that is a bit heavier on the theology than most of the fine-tuning works, but yet written by someone who knows science. This would necessarily limit the audience to believers—and that, I think, is exactly what I want.

I want to argue my case to believers who are antagonistic toward science—or who believe that the Ken Ham/Russell Humphreys young-earth view is the only way to reconcile science with the Bible.

I want to argue my case to believers who think that there is a scientific conspiracy to undermine Christianity.

I want to argue that in many cases we have met the enemy, and he is us.

Given that I am by most measures a “conservative” Christian, that is I affirm biblical inerrancy—well I think there would be some value hearing it from me rather than from a scientist who may be a liberal Christian.

A scientist who is a liberal Christian would have the perspective that the Bible is not authoritative or even reliable when it does (in rare cases) speak to science. They would reconcile the Bible and science by emphasizing their orthogonality.

I would take a completely different approach—superficially similar to that of the folks at Answers In Genesis (AiG), that the Bible is authoritative and reliable even when (in rare cases) it speaks of science. The difference would be that I think mainstream physics (old earth) is perfectly harmonious with scripture—while the AiG crowd does not.

There are other themes I can imagine including, many of which I blogged about. Perhaps most importantly is the disturbing elevation of blind faith to a pious virtue—in spite the absence of any scriptural support—and the consequential holier-than-thou mistrust of those who look for God not just in His word, but also in His creation.

Anyway, just thinking out loud.

Sunday, January 01, 2006

Ouch, that really hurts

On Wednesday I was skiing on Cannon Mountain in New Hampshire.

I didn’t make it through my second run.

It was my first time skiing Cannon, so obviously I was on an unfamiliar trail. I was already going fast when the trail suddenly turned steeper. I picked up speed, hit a bump, lost control, and fell.

At that point I was sliding on my back, backwards, at a fairly good clip. I was sliding down and across the trail, and soon came to the edge. Instead of being stopped by the netting that marks the border between the trail and the woods, I went under it, on my back, headfirst.

I came to a sudden stop when I hit a tree with my head. A literal head-on collision.

I was wearing a helmet, or I’d be dead.

I almost blacked out.

An off duty ski patroller stopped and pulled me out. (Off the trail, the snow was about three feet deep.) He asked me if I could ski the rest of the way. I said I thought I could, but then, when I stood up, I felt dizzy. After that, and especially after I told him (a) I hit a tree at high speed with my head and (b) two years ago I suffered an as-yet not completely healed herniated disc (C6) from another skiing accident (I collided with a demon snowboarder) he was not going to let me ski.

So I ended up on a backboard, strapped in, head, arms and legs immobilized. Fairly humiliating. They loaded me on a sled and skied me off the mountain, right to a waiting ambulance, and off to a hospital.

The worse part was in the ER. I was still strapped to the backboard, now placed on a gurney. The strap around my jaw was incredibly tight. It was hot, and I still had my ski jacket and, even worse, my ski boots. The nurses would not loosen the straps until a doctor checked me out, which took some time.

An angel of mercy took off my boots. And finally I got unstrapped. Off to radiology for X-rays, and everything looked OK. (The radiologist could detect my earlier injury—pretty impressive on an X-ray as opposed to an MRI.) While I was waiting, three or four other people were brought into the ER in the same state: immobilized on a backboard. Under one doctor’s lab coat, I could see a t-shirt that read: I survived ski-week in the ER.

The next day I felt as if I had been in a car wreck. My neck was very stiff, and my chest ached.

By Friday I was exercising again. Everything seems to be healing nicely. On Saturday night, New Year’s Eve, our church held its annual Hogmanay Ceilidh (Scottish folk dance.) The Master of Ceremonies, one Stuart of the Campbell clan, told of my incident to all those present for the festivities, and insisted that I wear a hard-hat during the dancing.

So much fun and excitement packed into one short week.

Friday, December 30, 2005

Lesson 3: Deity of Christ (Part 1)


(This is based on John Gerstner’s Primer on Biblical Inerrancy from a compilation of his primers in the book Primitive Theology. I am using Primitive Theology for my Sunday School class. There is a growing list of links on the left for the posts for this class.)

Today we take up the doctrine of the deity of Christ; the proclamation that Jesus if far more than a good teacher, far more than a prophet, far more than an angel: He is God. To prove this, we will look for both indirect and direct evidence from scripture.

Starting from this lesson we take as given what we all previously acknowledged: the bible is the infallible, inerrant, inspired word of God. This means we can trust the words of Christ as presented in the bible which, in turn, means that we can allow for Jesus to attest to His own divinity.

The absolute most direct possible statement, of Jesus saying “I am God,” is not found in scripture. However there is a wealth of scripture that leads to that inevitable conclusion.

One technique that is sometimes useful for determining whether a saying of Jesus is proclaiming His divinity is to repeat what He says but imagine that we are saying it about ourselves. If it sounds like blasphemy for us to say it, then it is an indirect piece of evidence that Christ is declaring his own divinity.

This doctrine of Christ’s divinity is constantly under attack from within the Church. From our study of Church History we recall than in the fourth century the church faced the Arian Heresy, which taught that Christ was a created being. At the council of Nicea in AD 325, the Church upheld as canonical the doctrine that Jesus was begotten, not made—and that his divine nature is of the same essence as the Father. That is, Jesus is not just similar to Deity, He is Deity.

Similar attacks on the deity of Christ have appeared throughout church history, and are still with us today.

The doctrine of the deity of Christ is the most important doctrine in Christianity. We will discuss other doctrines—predestination, justification, the nature of the Atonement etc. All these doctrines are subject, most would say, to reasonable debate within the family. Most people would say, for example, that one can be a proponent or opponent of Augustinian predestination and still be a Christian. The doctrine of the deity of Christ stands alone in that we all agree that you cannot be a Christian and deny that Jesus is God.

Some try—some claim that accepting Christ’s moral teachings is what makes one a Christian. You will find this view in the lunatic fringe liberal wing of Christendom. We will look at this in more detail, but for now we point out the obvious: virtually nobody denies that Christ’s moral teachings are “good.” If accepting that Christ’s moral teachings are correct, then not only are radical Protestants (such as Bishop Spong and Bishop Robinson) Christians, but so are Mormons and Moslems. Not only that, most atheists, by that definition, are Christians—for most atheist parents will attempt to teach their children, in some form, to love their neighbors as themselves.

Jesus as a Moral Teacher

Without question, Christ is a teacher or morality. But is he only a teacher of morality, or is he something more? Can one be a Christian simply by attempting one’s best at following Christ’s moral teaching?

The answer, according to Jesus, is no. Jesus himself tells us that he is more than a moral teacher: he is the source of our morality—so much so that we not only will not but we cannot follow his moral teachings without his power within us. This is in fact the message that distinguishes Jesus from other moral teachers:

Obey the golden rule, you can will yourself to do it!—human moralists

Obey the golden rule through my power which dwells within you—Jesus’ teaching

This is very significant. Christ’s teaching on morality goes way beyond his instructing us to obey the moral law—even though at times He does simply issue commandments and maxims. However, we find an important teaching in this regard in John’s gospel:
I am the vine; you are the branches. If a man remains in me and I in him, he will bear much fruit; apart from me you can do nothing. (John 15:5)
when Jesus tells us that He is the vine, his disciples are the branches, and the fruit they bear are the good works or, said in another way, the fruit they bear is moral conduct. Here Christ is teaching something significant: while the branch bears fruit, the ultimate source is the vine. While praising his teaching, Non-Christian moralists, while praising His moral teaching, would never ever give Christ the credit to be the source of their morality. No, they would claim something good within themselves as the source of their morality; they are in fact quite proud of their morality—which demonstrates that those non-Christians who live exemplary moral lives are only superficially following Christ’s teachings.

It is interesting to note that evolution claims that man’s morality evolved. They point out that our survival is enhanced by living in regulated, moral societies. That seems reasonable. But it also seems irreducibly complex. If we imagine a situation prior to the evolution of morality, a situation in which it was every man for himself—how did a mutated moral agent survive long enough to pass along the morality gene? It certainly is not obvious that evolution can explain morality.

At any rate, Jesus is certainly teaching the following: My disciples will display morality, and I am the source of that morality. Christ teaches us the golden rule:
So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you, for this sums up the Law and the Prophets. (Matt 7:11)
All “moralists” accept that, but He also teaches that our ability to fulfill all that commands rests in His power (as the vine) and not in ourselves. This view, which is equivalent to the view of doctrine of the total depravity of man, will never be accepted by non-Christians.

In Matthew 5, Jesus also teaches of another source of morality: God in heaven. He tells us:
In the same way, let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and praise your Father in heaven. (Matt. 5:16)
If the good works glorify God, then again, we can paraphrase Jesus’ teaching: Live morally, this will glorify God the Father. For this to be true, it must be that God, in effect, deserves the credit—is the source as it were—of our morality. Otherwise our moral actions would be self glorifying.

We see that on two occasions Jesus ascribes the ultimate source of morality as (1) himself , and (2) God the Father. So we can conclude that in doing so Jesus is indirectly claiming his own divinity. Imagine a moral though human teacher, for example, Aristotle. Would it not be absurd for Aristotle to claim that both he is the source of his student’s morality and that God is also the source?

Though indirect, it seems that Jesus’ claim of being more than the teacher of morality but also the provider thereof is tantamount to claiming His own deity. Furthermore, we see that anyone who claims to be a Christian because he follows the teachings of Christ is incorrect. To be a Christian is much more than to claim that Jesus’ teachings are a worthy basis for human society—that sentiment must be accompanied by an acknowledgement that we are such heinous sinners that we cannot hope to follow His teachings without drawing on His power

Identification with the Father as Proof of Jesus’ Divinity

Here is a more direct proof of Christ’s divinity. When Christ speaks to Philip, He says:
Jesus said to him, “Have I been with you so long, and yet you have not known Me, Philip? He who has seen Me has seen the Father; so how can you say, ‘Show us the Father’? (John 14:9)
This is, of course, equivalent to saying “He who has seen me has seen God.” What can Jesus mean by this statement?

One natural (though incorrect) way to interpret this statement is to say that Jesus meant something along the lines that God dwelt within him. But that is not what He meant. We can see that clearly if we note that God the Holy Spirit dwells within all believers. However, if Pastor Mike stood on the pulpit and stated that “He who has seen me has seen God” we would consider putting him out to pasture for his blasphemy. We know that Pastor Mike would never say that precisely because he knows that he is not God. Likewise, if Jesus knew that he was not God but just a moral teacher, he would not make such a statement. Therefore, the fact that He freely made the statement implies that He did claim divinity.

What Christ is really teaching when He states “He who has seen me has seen the Father” is nothing short of the Christian doctrine of the incarnation. He is describing his unity with God the Father, appearing on earth in a human form with a complete human nature.

Now on another occasion Jesus said:
My Father, who has given them to me, is greater than all; no one can snatch them out of my Father's hand. I and the Father are one." (John 10:29-30)
So Jesus claims: “I and the Father are one.” First of all, we note once again the absurdity of a non-deity making such a claim. If I stated: “I, David Heddle, and the Father are one” you would surely be scandalized. Once again we have Jesus claiming his deity by making a statement that a mere rational mortal could never utter.

These two statements, taken together, provide an interesting proof of the doctrine of the Trinity—even though the Holy Spirit is never mentioned! Here is the idea:

The first statement, “He who has seen me has seen the Father,” indicates an identity between Jesus and the Father. The statement “I and the Father are one” implies both an identity and diversity. In short, we see two persons—Jesus and the Father—but one Godhead. The reason that this can be viewed, in a sense, as a proof of the trinity (obviously to be supplemented with scripture related to the Holy Spirit) is that that a common objection to the trinity is not that it is three persons in one Godhead but that it is more than one person in the Godhead. But these two statements of Jesus already open that door—all that remains is to add the Holy Spirit.

Jesus Losing Disciples as Proof of His Divinity

In chapter eight of John’s gospel, we read the interesting account of Jesus losing disciples. The account begins with Jesus engaging in a dialogue (v. 31) with certain “Jews who believed on him”
To the Jews who had believed him, Jesus said, "If you hold to my teaching, you are really my disciples. Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free."(John 8:31-32)
By the end of the chapter, not only did these Jews not believe in Jesus, they wanted to kill him.

At first, they believed in Him. Then, they wanted to kill him. What happened in between? What happened was that in the course of the discussion they realized that Jesus was making claims that went way beyond the Jesus they “believed” in, a Jesus who was a great moral teacher or rabbi. They became agitated when Jesus taught that he came from the Father and was one with the Father. These disciples were getting the message, and they did not like it one bit. In due time they recognized that Jesus’ claim of deity, and they viewed His claim as blasphemy. The outrage of these Jewish believers can only be explained when we recognized that they certainly believed that Jesus was claiming to be God. In fact, scripture quite clearly speaks of their complaint: “You being a man make yourself out to be God.”

The statement “He who has seen me has seen the Father,” was made to believing disciples. They accepted Jesus’ claim of divinity. The statements from this portion of John 8 are made to believers who do not really believe. They reject the claim and try to execute Him.

To be continued.

Thursday, December 22, 2005

Lesson 2: Biblical Inerrancy (Part 7)

Private Interpretation


Private Interpretation is a concept that is closely connected with Sola Scriptura. Private Interpretation means that as we all are priests (1 Pet. 2:9, Rev. 5:9-10), so we all have the privilege of reading and discerning the Scriptures. In addition to this unfettered access being a privilege, it is also a grave responsibility.

This is a very important point: while we have the right to interpret scripture, we have the responsibility to avoid the pitfall of subjectivism. We are not free to invent our own truths from scripture. We are to apply sound principles in our interpretations. That includes giving due respect (without elevating to the level of inspired) commentaries of theologians and scholars who have studied the scriptures. Private interpretation does not mean you lock yourself in a room with nothing but a bible and, when you emerge, whatever you have discerned is good enough simply because you believe it sincerely.

The principle of Private Interpretation, along with the advent of scripture in the vernacular, are two of the great practical results of the Reformation. Both of these offshoots of the Reformation greatly damaged the Catholics Church’s desire to retain for herself the sole right to interpret scripture.

No wonder, then, that Catholics are not too keen on Private Interpretation. A common charge leveled against Protestants is that strict adherence to Sola Scriptura and affirmation of Private Interpretation results in a cacophony of opinions because some aspects of the scripture are simply not clear.

Sometimes Catholics use 2 Pet. 1:20 “knowing this first, that no prophecy of Scripture is of any private interpretation” to argue against private interpretation—in other words we should privately interpret this passage to tell ourselves that we cannot privately interpret. In truth, this verse refers to the fact that the prophets were messengers who gave prophecy—even as at times they misunderstood it. The “private interpretation” here refers to the prophet, not the reader. This is a recurring theme in Peter’s writings, where we also find:
Concerning this salvation, the prophets, who spoke of the grace that was to come to you, searched intently and with the greatest care, trying to find out the time and circumstances to which the Spirit of Christ in them was pointing when he predicted the sufferings of Christ and the glories that would follow. It was revealed to them that they were not serving themselves but you, when they spoke of the things that have now been told you by those who have preached the gospel to you by the Holy Spirit sent from heaven. Even angels long to look into these things. (1 Pet 1:10-12)
Another example of Rome's teaching against Private Interpretation is found in the Catholic Catechism:
The task of giving an authentic interpretation of the Word of God, whether in its written form or in the form of Tradition, has been entrusted to the living teaching office of the Church alone. Its authority in this matter is exercised in the name of Jesus Christ." This means that the task of interpretation has been entrusted to the bishops in communion with the successor of Peter, the Bishop of Rome. (Catholic Catechism, Part I, Section I, Chapter 2, Article 2, paragraph 85)

The Catholic Encyclopedia, in the “Protestantism” section, states:
Again, it is illogical to base faith upon the private interpretation of a book. For faith consists in submitting; private interpretation consists in judging. In faith by hearing the last word rests with the teacher; in private judgment it rests with the reader, who submits the dead text of Scripture to a kind of post-mortem examination and delivers a verdict without appeal.... Private judgment is fatal to the theological virtue of faith.... The open Bible and the open mind on its interpretation are rather a lure to entice the masses... The first limitation imposed on the application of private judgment is the incapacity of most men to judge for themselves on matters above their physical needs.
And the Council of Trent (1546) declared:
Furthermore, in order to restrain petulant spirits, it (Trent) decrees, that no one, relying on his own skill, shall - in all matters of faith, and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine - wresting the sacred Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said sacred Scripture contrary to that sense which Holy mother Church - whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the holy Scriptures - hath held and doth hold; or even contrary to the unanimous consent of the Fathers; even though such interpretations were never (intended) to be at any time published. Contraveners shall be made known by their Ordinaries, and be punished with the penalties by law established.
Now, at first glance, Rome’s criticism has some merit. We have Calvinists and Arminians. Infant Baptism and Adult (Believer’s) Baptism. Baptism by sprinkling, baptism by immersion. Some churches come to the Lord's Supper weekly, some monthly, some at other intervals. Not to mention at least four millennial views with sizable numbers of adherents.

This diversity, some would say, is the inevitable result of Sola Scriptura. On those issues in which scripture is not clear, people will interpret scripture differently.

Our Catholic critics are, of course, absolutely correct. When scripture is not completely clear, then a concept, no matter how important it may be to its champions, is downgraded from an essential to a liberty issue, or at least there is a implicit recognition that: I believe this but I might be wrong; I can have Christian fellowship with those of an opposing view.

The problem with this criticism is that it doesn’t criticize an actual fault. It is one group saying to another that "your house is not as tidy as my house, so you must be doing something wrong."

Protestants, of course, deny that either sacred tradition or church councils (or any church official) has any authority to bind the conscience. We would say that the uniformity enjoyed by the Roman Catholic Church is unlawfully imposed and, while it achieves uniformity, there is no guarantee that, on any given issue, it is not uniformly wrong.

We agree on the essentials, the essentials that we can discerned unambiguously from scripture. The essentials include things like the divinity of Christ, the Incarnation, the Atonement, the Resurrection, and the Trinity. Disagree with an essential, and you have slid into apostasy.

The rest, we say, will be sorted out later.

The fact that we can agree to disagree (by no means, to our shame, always peacefully) on interpretation is utterly un-Catholic. This is perfectly illustrated by an anecdote from James Kennedy (Coral Ridge Ministries) during a panel discussion entitled “Irreconcilable Differences” that examined the differences that persist between Rome and evangelicals. Kennedy said:
[A] few weeks ago, I was out on visitation, and I ended up in a home where there were seventeen people present. There was a family that were in our new member class. There was a visiting family that were a part of our sponsors that happened to be there. There were a bunch of kids, and there was a mother of one of the adults there, an elderly woman from Brooklyn and she was a Roman Catholic. Now there were some other relatives there—they came from five or six, maybe different churches and backgrounds. I went around and asked them these questions: I asked each of them, one by one, "In what were they trusting for their hope of eternal life. Why should God admit them into heaven?" This woman, before, had said, with a little bit of hostility, that she thought it was terrible that there was all these different religions. Everybody had their own religion, there own views, they are all different, and she didn't like this idea that everybody had a different religion—they all ought to be one. It was fascinating to see that one, after another, after another—the person said the reason God should let me into heaven is:

"Christ died for my sins."
"Jesus paid for my sins."
"I have no hope but Christ."
"By the grace of God, through faith in Christ alone"
"It was through Christ who died for me."
"I put my trust in Jesus Christ."
"Christ paid for my sins."
"I am trusting in Jesus Christ."
"Christ is my Savior."
"I have no hope but Jesus."

And on and on it went, and this woman said, "Because I'm good!" But she was stunned by the fact that what she thought were all of these different churches, in disunity, were all in perfect unity when it came to the essence of the gospel. I think as John has said, there is a unity of Christians, of true believers. You can go anywhere in the world, as many of you have, and you will find a person is a true Christian and you have discovered a brother or a sister in Christ, regardless of what denomination he's in—if he really trusts in Christ. You have been joined together in one, and you are one in Him.

Wednesday, December 21, 2005

Hoisted with our own Petards

ID suffered a big loss yesterday. Not because it cannot be in the science curriculum in the Dover Schools—it didn’t belong there in the first place—but because its image is presently in the pits.

The loss is deeper than it would first seem. ID is now persona non grata. In my science classes in public school—precursors to ID always came up for discussion. As I have blogged about before, those rabbit trails made science class more interesting to the entire 2D spectrum of students: weak to strong, atheist to theist. Those discussions are now effectively, if not actually, illegal—at least if they are initiated by the teacher. (If initiated by a student, a teacher will, most likely, feel compelled to stifle the thread.)

So where does ID go from here?

My suggestion—stop the politics, do the science.

Is ID science? My view, which I have expressed before, is that it is not—although I doubt if Judge Jones knows science from Shinola. I have no idea if my view is a minority view among IDers. It probably is—I rarely seem to be the majority.

At the moment, I think that ID, and this applies to both the cosmological and biological varieties, does not make any meaningful, testable predictions. This criticism also applies Susskind’s String Theory Landscape and other “acceptable” frameworks, but that’s their problem. The playing field isn't level, but unfortunately nothing can be done about it.

ID is scientific. It lives in the world of science—it tries to explain, in the broadest sense, all the data. That’s fine and valuable—but it is not the same thing as saying: go to the lab and do this experiment that has never been done, and I predict you’ll find X if ID is true but Y if the prevailing theory is true.

Let’s face it—we are not there. I don’t think we are even very close. At the moment we have only negative predictions, such as another universe will not be detected or there is no evolutionary pathway that can explain this biological system—those do not count. A scientific theory must do more than point to the problems of other models.

Should IDers give up? Of course not. The idea that God not only created the universe but left evidence of His creation is legitimate, worthy, noble and probably true. (That is—the part about leaving evidence is probably true—the idea that God created the universe is not part of the ID debate—only the evidence-left-behind question is relevant.)

What IDers should do two-fold:
  1. They should do science.
  2. They should do ID.

Doing Science

Too many people on both sides of the debate (including plenty of the most obnoxious bigmouths on the evolution side) are not doing any science. They are doing politics and talking or writing about someone else’s science. ID scientists (that is, scientists who are pro-ID) should do research and write peer-reviewed papers the same way science has been done for, now, hundreds of years. The papers will not be ID papers—they will be “politically” indistinguishable from other research papers. ID scientists should give talks, teach classes, attend conferences—discussing and presenting what is indisputably science. Nothing makes a scientist more credible than an impressive vita. ID scientists should be working on having impeccable scientific credentials.

Doing ID

After first taking care of the science, scientists are free to take care of the ID. Write popular books—give popular lectures—give radio and television interviews. Talk to youth groups. Talk to college groups. Talk passionately about how amazing science is and how it points to a creator. This activity should be viewed as a ministry that parallels a scientific career, not a career in and of itself. Nobel laureates such as Penzias or Townes talking about ID are worth an infinite number of lawyers fighting about ID. A scientist who is doing and publishing science while engaging in ID “on the side” will be viewed by his peers as eccentric—which is never a problem in science. The science community doesn’t care what else you do, as long as your science is solid. However, a person who does ID but no science is viewed as a fraud.

In the future, it may be that ID will make concrete predictions. At that time it can rightfully claim the mantle of science. In the meantime, ID has a lot to offer and a lot of work to do.

Let’s stop picking the wrong fights to fight. If you hope that science can someday show that ID is right and evolution is wrong, the best thing you can do at the moment is have the current generation learn as much as they can about evolution.

Tuesday, December 20, 2005

The Dover Decision

In the Dover ID trial, Judge Jones has ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, i.e., against the ID side of the debate.

The Discovery Institute’s response is here.

And Jonathan Witt’s analysis is here.

My view on this matter may not align with others on the ID side. Although this case wasn’t directly about cosmological ID, there are huge ramifications—although they (the ramifications) are largely already, de facto, in place. Primarily: there is no chance for any of us of the ID side to continue giving seminar-like ID talks in public high schools. No principal would permit it even though, as I understand it (I might be wrong) this ruling would not prohibit it. It’s just too much of a hot potato. Anyway, I have never been in favor of legal maneuvering to get ID into the science curriculum. Not only because I disagree in principle, but from a practical standpoint it was obvious that in today’s America that such efforts were ultimately doomed and would result in a backlash. This is in fact what has happened.

There was not much doubt about the final outcome. The unknowns were: How activist is this judge? How far would he go? What degree of omniscience would he assume? The answers: very activist, he went very far, and he assumed godlike omniscience although without the attendant infallibility.

This was a lose-lose for everyone—although obviously the anti-ID side is crowing over their perceived victory. The problem is, today’s favorable (from whoever's perspective) judicial intrusion into an area where it doesn’t belong opens the door for tomorrow’s nightmarish decision.

In my opinion, the correct, founding-father-like ruling would have been: the school board was legally voted in—and what they decide to put in their curriculum is not the federal government’s business—and if you don’t like them, vote them out. (Which is in fact what has already happened.)

Judge Jones ruled that ID is not science. Of course, one wonders on what basis he is qualified to say what is or isn’t science. (Maybe he explains somewhere in the 139 pages, I’m working off blurbs.) If it includes testability and falsifiability, it would be interesting to ask the judge how evolution is testable, and how evolution is falsifiable. (I’m not saying evolution isn’t either of those. I’m speculating that Judge Jones wouldn’t know how to answer—and yet his is ruling on what constitutes science.)

Jone’s wrote:
In making this determination, we have addressed the seminal question of whether ID is science. We have concluded that it is not, and moreover that ID cannot uncouple itself from its creationist, and thus religious, antecedents.
This is the old ID == creationism canard, which Jones bought hook, line and sinker. But in fact, ID is creationism only if you define that anything consistent with theism is creationist. I was called a creationist on a physics website the other day, when asked for the definition, the physicist in question wrote†:
"A creationist is a person who believes that one of the most crucial insights about our existence and the existence of our Universe is that they have been *created* by a supreme being, and that this insight should have a significant impact on our lives including science."
By this definition, which I think is fair, I would venture to guess that many if not most IDers are indeed creationists. I would also think that this labels theistic evolutionists as creationists—and the anti-ID side would not want to admit to that.

But calling IDers creationists, as Judge Jones did, identifies, whether intentionally or not, ID as young earth creationism part deux. But ID is very different from young earth creationism. In my opinion, ID is consistent with all scientific data (in fact, a criticism of ID is that it will always be consistent with all data) while young earth creationism is inconsistent with all data. ID: consistent with all data. YEC: inconsistent with all data. That is a big difference.

So… we’ll have to put up a few days of nauseating backslapping.


†In my opinion, this willingness to provide a definition of creationist demonstrates yet again the superiority of physicists. I have never seen anyone on Panda’s Thumb define creationist, although they use the term more often than they use the letter ‘m’.