Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Sunday School on Science and Faith

I haven't taught Sunday School since moving to Virginia. That's about to change. I will teach on a familiar topic, and will post the notes here. Much of the notes will be taken from previous blogs posts--which were take from previous Sunday School Notes, so I am no longer sure which came first. At any rate, they may look familiar. Below the line is the tentative outline.


Science and Faith

This Sunday School series will deal with the tension between science and faith. It is important to remember that I am not an elder in this church—my views on these matters are strictly my own and in no way endorsed by Grace Baptist Chapel. I certainly hope that we can enjoy an iron-sharpens-iron civil discourse on the topics—some of which are likely to be a bit controversial.

The outline for the series is:

  1. Introduction
    1. Special Revelation and Theology.
    2. General Revelation and Science.
    3. God is not a god of confusion.
    4. Christians v. Scientists. What's the score?

  2. What is science? What is not science?
    1. Philosophical Naturalism: The cosmos is all there is.
    2. Methodological Naturalism: Let's operate as if the cosmos is all there is.
    3. Show me the experiment!

  3. Blind Faith—Does the Bible present it as a virtue?
    1. Hebrews 11 seems to say yes, until, oddly enough…
    2. Hebrews 11 seems to prove otherwise.

  4. The Genesis Days
    1. What does yom mean?
    2. Can we literally take this literally?
    3. Rabbit Trail: the Tree of Life.

  5. The Church Fathers
    1. Oops: it seems that on that day, Adam surely did not die.
    2. There's Justin, Irenaeus, Clement of Alexandria, Origen, and finally…
    3. St. Augustine: the most radical non-literalist.

  6. Intelligent Design
    1. Good: Intelligent Design as an apologetic.
    2. Bad: The Intelligent Design Movement and the culture wars.
    3. Ugly: The poor witness and the proclamation of victimhood.

  7. The cosmological fine tunings—the Multiverse or Multiple Verses?
    1. The universe on a razor's edge.
    2. Don't touch that constant!
    3. Is it luck, multiple universes, or God in the details?

  8. Who can be a Christian? Is theistic evolution incompatible with Christianity?
    1. Remember, we are Protestants.
    2. Remember, we are Calvinists.
    3. Think of the Children!

  9. Summary


UPDATE: The posts for this Sunday School, which begins May 25, will also be availaible on this site.

Finals Week

The reason people become professors is to be on the other side of those dreaded final exams.

Not really. They are a huge pain in the derriere for us, too, although the students are not sympathetic to our plight.

When students ask me for help on a homework, my first response (which I try to keep to once per student, lest I be viewed as senile) is "If I knew how to do it, then I wouldn't be asking you." Then I help.

Inevitably, as I am passing out a test, some student will ask "How is it?" I will always reply with a deadpan "Man, I'm glad I don't have to take it."

Strangely this always breaks the ice. I am reminded that Johnny Cash always claimed that the songs his legions of incarcerated fans enjoyed most were not the songs of freedom, songbirds, and blue skies. No, they liked the songs telling of the prison inmate's gloom and despair.

Monday, May 05, 2008

Baylor and Gomorrah

Denyse O'Leary has a real problem with Baylor University. and she views Baylor President John Lilley as a minion of the antichrist. Baylor and Lilley have committed several unpardonable sins, viz., 1) they unceremoniously showed O'Leary's friend and guru Bill Dembski the door, at least twice. 2) By refusing to require the Baylor Board of Regents to wear scarlet M's (for Materialist) they forced Dembski to publish, as a public service to the many sane commenters on his blog, the board members' addresses and home phone numbers, and 3) They made Robert Marks move his virtual lab to a private web server. To recover his lab, and this makes the mind reel, it required two, yes two invocations of ftp.

On a recent Uncommon Descent post, Denyese reports on a letter that Lilley addressed, it would seem, to those who have complained (I'm sure without any inciting from from that bastion of graciousness and decency, Uncommon Descent) that Baylor is BINO†.

O'Leary complains that Lilley's letter says nothing. Actually I think it says "stop being ignorant asses" without actually saying "stop being ignorant asses."

Along the way, O'Leary manages to dis Francis Collins (again), which is a bit like Paula Abdul dissing The New York Times entertainment writers.

But I bring all this up because in complaining about Lilley's letter, O'Leary, wittingly or not, but in any case with impressive conciseness, summarizes the wrongheadedness of the thinking on Uncommon Descent in particular and the Intelligent Design Movement in general. She writes that Lilley said nothing at all,
Unless, that is, you believe faith and science are in conflict, in which case he [Lilley] reassures you that they aren’t.

But if you do believe that, why would you want to attend or fund Baylor - or any religiously affiliated university?
That is Uncommon-Descent-Think in a nutshell: Faith and science are in conflict; God is a god of confusion. Why would you support any Christian university that teaches the blasphemous doctrine of the harmony of faith and science?

She nailed it.

(Well, faith and science in conflict is their material cause. Their final cause is that they are being unmercifully persecuted out of existence.)


†Baptist In Name Only. See this comment. This is reminiscent of Liberty University, whose faculty and administration, in my experience, customarily refer to other Christian schools that don't require an affirmation of YECism and premillennial dispensationalism as “CINO,” or Christian In Name Only.

Weirdest Amazon Order, Evah


This has to be the strangest Amazon order I ever placed. Three Items:
  1. The paperback version of The God Delusion, which will be used as a gift. (Yes, to someone I like.)
  2. A copy of the hardcover version of Feynman’s classic three volume set of introductory physics lectures—a gift to myself. My well-used paperback version is falling apart.
  3. A copy of John Hagee's Jerusalem Countdown. (Revised and updated!). Hagee is, to put it politely, a bat-shit crazy apocalypse cultist/svengali useful-idiot. I can hardly stomach reading anything he writes, but I know some Christians who are referring to him favorably so I want to remind myself of the awfulness of his false-prophetic arguments.
If this order doesn't crash Amazon's "recommendation” algorithm" I don’t know what will. I hope, although there is little chance, that on the page for The God Delusion it says, at least for a while, that "People who bought this book also bought Jerusalem Countdown."

Thursday, May 01, 2008

Learn Nuclear Physics in One Easy Sentence!

That one sentence is: When nuclei get bigger, they get bigger, but when atoms get bigger, they get smaller.

What is meant is this: As you move up the periodic table, you get more protons and more electrons. This means the attraction between the protons and electrons grows, and the electrons are pulled closer to the nucleus. (There are exceptions—we are talking trends.) Thus the paradoxical statement: when atoms get bigger (more charge) they get smaller (electrons pulled closer.)

Nuclei, on the other hand just get bigger when they get bigger.

This means the nuclear force that binds nuclei is fundamentally different than the electromagnetic force that binds atoms. Long range forces like the attraction between charges (which is of infinite range--though only weakly, a proton on one side of the solar system will feel the force of an electron on the other) cause the behavior we see in atoms. Short range forces, that are very strong only at short distances and zero at larger distances, cause the behavior we see in nuclei (bigger means bigger.) Why? Because the nuclear force has a short range, something like the size of a proton, neutrons and protons in a nucleus see only their nearest neighbors. Adding more neutrons or protons doesn't increase the attraction--because they don't even "see" most of their colleagues.

Thus this simple observation teaches us that the nuclear force is short ranged, which is the beginning point of all nuclear physics.

UPDATE: I've been a bloggin' too long and I'm getting too long in the tooth--I forgot that I had already blogged about this--only much better.

Friday, April 25, 2008

Take me out to the Simpson's Paradox

What a great example from wikipedia.


In case the "paradox" isn't clear--for three years David Justice had a higher batting average than Derek Jeter. If the Yankess GM was going to base their next contract on their hitting over these three years, he might say to himself: Justice hit better three years in a row. He gets more money. Jeter might even concede the reasonableness of the decision.

It would be the wrong decision. Even though Jeter lost the competition every year--his cumulative average is higher. He deserves the bigger contract.

God, the Physical Evidence

This was going top be a comment on a thread on another blog, but I decided to make it a post.

In the science-faith bloghetto, there are often demands for proof of God. Now theologically we know such a thing is impossible, for John tells us in his gospel that we cannot see the kingdom of God unless we are born again. If you are not born again, you are blind, and if you are blind, you can't see the proof—which puts you in one helluva predicament. But hey, that's what grace and divine initiative are all about, and that predicament perfectly explains why we need a savior.

But is there really no physical evidence? Well, there certainly is not scientific evidence in the sense that "if you do this experiment and get a result A, that will be proof of God."

But there is prima facie for the existence of God. And the strongest such evidence is the success of godless materialism, or methodological naturalism if you prefer, or better yet let's use its common name: science.

Now the argument is quite simple. The bible tells us things like the heavens declare God's glory and that the study of creation (that would be science) leaves men without excuse. As I read it, if science leaves men without excuse, then science must be possible. That is, a prediction of the bible is that science, if is to leave us without excuse, will work.

But science could easily be a fool's errand. If the simplest physical laws were not linear differential equations, science would be dead in the water. The very fact that man's intellect can comprehend science, is capable of developing theories, and most amazingly the theories are amenable to mathematical analysis is taken more or less for granted, but it shouldn't be. When a scientist tells you that science requires no faith or presupposition, he either isn't being honest or hasn't thought it through. All of us who are scientists work under the presupposition that we at least have a good chance to be successful—that all of a sudden nature will not decide that enough of her secrets have been revealed.

A purely naturalistic view (tell me if I'm wrong) has no reason to expect that science is not as fool's errand. The mathematics could have been so hard as to have forced Newton to give up. But from the bible we get a simple prediction that science will be doable. The success of science, my friends, is prima facie physical evidence that God exist, because the only other explanation is luck.

Science should be embraced, not feared. Every advancement of science is a feather in the cap of the faith community. Don't view it as a nail in our coffin.

Tuesday, April 22, 2008

Tonight is the night...

I will go see Expelled. I'll be going with another Ph.D. physicist/professor/devout-Christian/active scientific researcher. We're all over the place. Get used to it! That person sitting next to you at the ballgame might be a scientist and a Christian.

My expectations for Expelled are extremely low, so I'm guessing the movie will not be as bad as I fear. We'll see. My fear, by the way, is that it pits science against faith.

However, I will comment that the screen-hopping advocated by some is a form of outright theft. Don't bother telling me all the things that the Expelled producers may have done that strain the concept of Christian ethics. That may indeed be the case. Regardless, buying a ticket to a different movie and then slipping into Expelled is theft of intellectual property, pure and simple. As is downloading pirated copies.

Here is one Pharyngulan wrestling with the ethical question. I'm pulling for the right choice.

Derec, however, has opted to be a garden variety low-class thief.

Kudos to Panda's Thumb charter member Wes Elsberry. He took the ethical line on screen hopping.

Here you can find many people who advocate stealing.

It is wrong, absolutely wrong, regardless of what unsavory tactics were adopted by the Expelled gang.

Monday, April 21, 2008

One Son per Family

I am teaching a bit of probability in my mathematical methods class. One of my favorite intro problems is this:

China has a "one child" policy. This policy is problematic (and, at times, downright murderous) in a society that values sons over daughters. It has been suggested that a more popular and humane policy would be a "one son" rule. With this policy, every married couple could keep having children until they had their first son, then they could have no more.

Assuming that for any pregnancy a son or a daughter is equally probable, what would be the long term effect of this policy on the distribution of boys and girls in China?

Thursday, April 17, 2008

Fishputer





Students from our department built a "fishputer." That is, they took all the components from a Dell computer and immersed them (I guess it's a Baptist fishputer) in a tank of mineral oil. A debate rages as to whether or not the fan--which is operating, does anything of value. Also being pondered is whether or not you could load the computer with a CPU intensive code--perhaps, for example, calculating the Complex Specified Information of, oh, I don't know--say a kumquat, until the processor heats up to the flash point of mineral oil and the fishputer explodes.

It is inevitable that plastic fish will soon appear in the tank. A little CNU student in cement overshoes would be a nice touch.

I'll keep you posted.