Wednesday, May 02, 2007

YEC HQ

This site, the YEC headquarters, makes me sad.

As you probably know, it is not YEC per se that bothers me—it's the attitude among dogmatic YECs that only YECs are true Christians. That fairly common viewpoint is alternately infuriating and depressing. The elevation of a non-essential into an essential—the history of Christianity is so littered with that mistake that it confirms Santayana as a sage. There is a reason that there is no detailed statement on either creation or the end-times in the historic creeds—it's an area where the early church understood that it was OK to agree to disagree. Those who believe six days = 144 hours? The early church had them. Those who believe six days = six thousand years? The early church had them too. Care to believe six days were instantaneous? The early church accepts you, Bishop Augustine. (My God wouldn't need to take six long days!) I will confidently speculate that had there been any reason in those days to believe the earth was old, the early church would have accommodated that as well. As long as you affirmed:
We believe in one God, the Father, the Almighty, maker of heaven and earth, of all that is, seen and unseen. We believe in one Lord, Jesus Christ, the only Son of God, eternally begotten of the Father, God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made, of one Being with the Father. Through him all things were made. For us and for our salvation he came down from heaven: by the power of the Holy Spirit he became incarnate from the Virgin Mary, and was made man. For our sake he was crucified under Pontius Pilate; he suffereddeath and was buried. On the third day he rose again in accordance with the Scriptures; he ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of the Father. He will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead, and his kingdom will have no end.

We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of life, who proceeds from the Father and the Son. With the Father and the Son he is worshiped and glorified. He has spoken through the Prophets. We believe in one holy catholic and apostolic Church. We acknowledge one baptism for the forgiveness of sins. We look for the resurrection of the dead, and the life of the world to come. Amen.

Well we've come a long way baby.

An anathema on this nasty dogmatic YEC Council-of-Trent–like anathematizing of the OECs. Last year I discussed this viewpoint at length in a post entitled: Spiritual Arrogance, The Garden of Eden, and How I Learned Not To Worry That A Dead Mouse Could Render Jesus Inconsequential.

Hunt around this YEC HQ site and you'll find, among other things, why God and Science will never mix. At least there is some gallows humor here; those who would agree with the author include Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris.

This is just wrong. Surely the writer knows that the bible tells us that the sheer wonderment of creation leaves all men without excuse. Why does he then want to neuter the means (science) used to study that creation? Does he not know that Adam was the first scientist, a biologist even, when he developed the first taxonomy?

Grr.

Letters from Luke

Luke is my autistic son. I've written about him here, which partly (or perhaps entirely) explains my irrational disdain for Christian schools, and here in which I discuss his amazing memory.

Luke has just started using email. His first email arrived, unexpectedly, the other day whilst I was struggling at work. It cheered me up immensely, to make an understatement.

I'll privilege you with a peek at our first round of exchanges. That's all you get—the rest are mine to savor alone.

Some background: Like many people with autism, Luke is very literal. Metaphors are not something that he can grasp. However, he is also mischievous about his literality. For example, he noticed that some intersections have a "No Left Turn on Red Arrow" sign—reminding drivers that even though the light is green for vehicles going straight, you can't turn left. So every time we come to a similar intersection without that sign, Luke says to me: "Since there is no sign that says you can't turn left on red, that means you can turn left on red." To which I reply "Oh, OK" and start moving forward as if I'll make the turn—and then Luke will say "Ah, no. I'm just kidding."

That is so you might grasp the references to hats and the National Anthem. The basic story is that we were at a baseball game and the announcer said "Please remove your caps." So Luke will often say, with an impish grin, "He said remove your caps, so that means I don't have to remove my [cowboy hat, space visor, etc.]"

The other thing you'll probably figure out is Luke likes palindromes.


Luke Heddle to me (Apr 24)

Dear Dad,
I love you so much and you love me too. What are we going to do in Pittsburgh when we go there in the summer?

Love,
Luke


David Heddle to Luke (Apr 24)

Luke,
Yes I do love you very much.

I hope we can see a Pirates game at the new stadium.

Luke, what is:

Do geese see God?

spelled backwards?

Dad


Luke Heddle to me (Apr 27)

At the Pirates game when I stand for "The National Anthem", I don't have to remove my Red Sox hat, my Patriots hat, or my NASCAR hat (like Kevin Harvick, Robby Gordon, Tony Stewart, etc.) because I'm at a Pirates game. And he said, remove your caps. He didn't say remove your cowboy hat. He didn't say remove your mask either. In "Monster House", Chowder wore a mask.



David Heddle to Luke (Apr 27)
Luuuuuuke!

You do have to remove ANY hat for the national anthem!

What is:

Too bad I hid a boot

spelled backwards?

Dad


Luke Heddle to me (May 1)

I don't have to remove my squishy hat when I stand for "The National Anthem" because the man didn't say remove your squishy hat.


David Heddle to Luke (May 1)
Oh yes you do, you must remove any hat, including a space visor.

Luke what is:

Was it Eliot's toilet I saw?

spelled backwards?

Dad

Stare at this for a while...

New Template

So I switched to the blogger "layout" scheme (and away from the archaic "classic template" manually edited css-based quagmire.) I'm not sure of all the ramifications yet. I will restore links and other sidebar elements as quickly as possible.

The main reason I switched is I was using the same template I started with in 2002! Except that it has been unmercifully hacked into an inpenetrable, unmaintainable morass.

The old haloscan comments seem to be there--while (this post will be the test) the new comments should be from blogger.

UPDATE: ok by some magic the comments, even on the new post, are still haloscan. So be it.

Tuesday, May 01, 2007

Hitchens's New Book

Slate has excerpts from gadfly Christopher Hitchens's new book God is Not Great. From what Slate posted, presumably meant to entice or intrigue, I know one thing: I will not read this book. Hitchens's arguments are so unoriginal and his style so churlish (and yet ostentatious) that I cannot imagine reading anything lengthier than these excerpts, and even struggling through those short samples of his annoying prose felt like mental root-canal.

Don't get me wrong—I can read critics of religion. In fact, I enjoy the exercise. I don't get emotionally distraught. (With the possible exception of the writings of Bishop John Shelby Spong, whose material is an effective emetic.) But if I take the time to read a critic then please, at least let him be original, even if just occasionally. Hitchens, (at least based on the Slate excerpts) like Dawkins in The God Delusion, commits the unforgivable sin of being boring. Contrast Sam Harris who, to his credit, at least offerd some new perspectives in his atheistic/mystical rant. Sam Harris was quite fun to read.

Hitchens, it seems to me, even anticipates that he has nothing new to say, writing:

There are four irreducible objections to religious faith: that it wholly misrepresents the origins of man and the cosmos, that because of this original error it manages to combine the maximum of servility with the maximum of solipsism, that it is both the result and the cause of dangerous sexual repression, and that it is ultimately grounded on wish-thinking.

I do not think it is arrogant of me to claim that I had already discovered these four objections (as well as noticed the more vulgar and obvious fact that religion is used by those in temporal charge to invest themselves with authority) before my boyish voice had broken. I am morally certain that millions of other people came to very similar conclusions in very much the same way, and I have since met such people in hundreds of places, and in dozens of different countries.

He's right—we've all heard such objections a semi-infinite number of times. Yawn. Hitchens has plagiarized untold numbers of late night dorm room philosophers.

Let's see—can we dig out any new insight from the Slate excerpts?

We [atheists] may differ on many things, but what we respect is free inquiry, openmindedness, and the pursuit of ideas for their own sake.

Translation: we atheists are supremely rational. Nope, heard that one before.

We are not immune to the lure of wonder and mystery and awe: we have music and art and literature, and find that the serious ethical dilemmas are better handled by Shakespeare and Tolstoy and Schiller and Dostoyevsky and George Eliot than in the mythical morality tales of the holy books.

Translation: Though supremely rational, we atheists also appreciate the sublime. Nope, heard that one before.

We do not believe in heaven or hell, yet no statistic will ever find that without these blandishments and threats we commit more crimes of greed or violence than the faithful. (In fact, if a proper statistical inquiry could ever be made, I am sure the evidence would be the other way.)

Translation: we atheists don't need no stinkin' heaven or hell to keep us in line. Nope, heard that one before.

We believe with certainty that an ethical life can be lived without religion. And we know for a fact that the corollary holds true—that religion has caused innumerable people not just to conduct themselves no better than others, but to award themselves permission to behave in ways that would make a brothel-keeper or an ethnic cleanser raise an eyebrow.

Translation: we atheists don't need religion to define our morality. In fact, we behave better than the religious whose so-called morality often lands them in the gutter. Nope, heard that one before.

How many needless assumptions must be made, and how much contortion is required, to receive every new insight of science and manipulate it so as to "fit" with the revealed words of ancient man-made deities? How many saints and miracles and councils and conclaves are required in order first to be able to establish a dogma and then—after infinite pain and loss and absurdity and cruelty—to be forced to rescind one of those dogmas?

Translation: we atheists are amazed at the hoops you'll jump through to reconcile religion with science. Nope, heard that one before.

The mildest criticism of religion is also the most radical and the most devastating one. Religion is man-made.

Hmm.. religion is an invention of men. Nope, heard that one before.

As I write these words, and as you read them, people of faith are in their different ways planning your and my destruction, and the destruction of all the hard-won human attainments that I have touched upon. Religion poisons everything.

Translation: The theists are out to destroy us and establish a medieval American theocracy! Religion is the source of everything that is wrong in the world! Nope, heard that one before.

If you can refrain from buying but one book this year, I recommend God is Not Great without reservation.

Hat Tip: Evolution Blog

Hold on...

Playing with new templates, give me a moment (or a few)...

This could result in weeping and gnashing of teeth...

UPDATE: Back to old template--the haloscan wizard for installing comments in the new blogger layouts crashed and burned. I don't want to throw away all the comments, so I'll wait for a solution from haloscan.

The Drama of Redemption (Lesson 1, Part 2)

This is a new Sunday School series which will be largely based on R. C. Sproul’s audio series The Drama of Redemption, available from his website.

Lesson 1: Part 1


§1. The Eternal Drama


Sproul entitled his series The Drama of Redemption. His point is not that the story of redemption is dramatic fiction—but that it is a well directed, well crafted true-life drama—a reality show if you will. We all are actors, but some have leading roles. God the Father, God the Son, God the Holy Spirit. Angels and men, men like Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, David and the apostles. And there is unfolding action that spans history. This plan of God's is not a Rube Goldberg contraption—it is orderly, efficient and precise.

What we'll see, contrary to our view of the Old Testament as rather haphazard, is that this comprehensive story of redemption has a structure to it. And the skeletal framework of this structure is comprised of the biblical covenants. This does not mean that we must approach of God's redemptive plan through the eyes of what is called Covenant Theology. Both Covenant Theology and Dispensationalism agree that there has been a series of biblical covenants referenced in scripture.

Now a covenant is an agreement or pact. It stipulates what two parties bring to the table, and what they receive. A covenant is usually of mutual benefit. Sometimes covenants are between equal partners, such as the marriage covenant. Other times they are between unequal partners, such as the agreement between an employer and the employee. In the case of covenants between God and man they are 1) between infinitely unequal partners, 2) acts of grace: God is not obligated to enter into any sort of contract with his creation, and 3) unlike human-human covenants that are negotiated, covenants between God and man are unilaterally imposed by God. Man does warrant a seat at the negotiating table,

However, none of that applies to the first covenant that we will discuss: the Covenant of Redemption which reformed theologians (most of them) state is inferred from scripture.

There are two unique features of the Covenant of Redemption:

  1. It doesn't involve man; the parties in this covenant are the members of the Godhead: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.

  2. It was agreed upon prior to creation.

The Covenant of Redemption is an agreement among the three persons of the Trinity, established before the earth was created. It is the agreement that the Father would give a people to His son, the Son would perform the work necessary to redeem them, and the Spirit would sanctify them and give them second life.
18For you know that it was not with perishable things such as silver or gold that you were redeemed from the empty way of life handed down to you from your forefathers, 19but with the precious blood of Christ, a lamb without blemish or defect. 20He was chosen before the creation of the world, but was revealed in these last times for your sake. (1 Pet. 1:18-20)

Peter teaches quite explicitly that Christ's role in redemption was not devised after the fall, or after the Jews failed in their obedience, but that it was already in place even before creation. For he chose us in him before the creation of the world to be holy and blameless in his sight, Paul writes (Eph. 1:4).

The online encyclopedia Wikipedia defines the Covenant of Redemption rather well:

The Covenant of Redemption is the eternal agreement within the Godhead in which the Father appointed the Son Jesus Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit to redeem the elect from the guilt and power of sin. God appointed Christ to live a life of perfect obedience to the law and to die a penal, substitutionary, sacrificial death as the covenantal representative for all who trust in him.

This covenant is not appreciated by many Christians. Many view Christ's work not as a voluntary commitment from all eternity, but as a corrective measure. God made man, this way of thinking goes, and hoped that man would not fall. But fall man did: strike one. And after man fell, it is reasoned, God provided a way out for the Jews. But they were never able to respond with the required obedience: strike two. And so, to correct these mistakes, or perhaps to change the Father's mind, Christ had to come. A homerun off an 0-2 pitch.

This view is simply not true. As scripture clearly teaches, Christ knew he'd be coming to redeem a people before any people existed. His role was established prior to creation.

Since somone asked...

By request, links to previous Sunday School lessons on Roman Catholicism:

Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
Part 5
Part 6
Part 7
Part 8
Part 9
Part 10
Part 11
Part 12
Part 13

Response to Crandaddy’s comment

This is a quick response to Crandaddy’s comment on yesterday’s post.

Might it ever have occurred to you that possibly, maybe there might just be something else to ID besides dishonest Christian apologists trying to smuggle creationism into schools?
Yes, I’ve written many times that ID has an important role, as an (honest) apologetic. Science in general and especially its great mysteries and potential discontinuities make for fantastic apologetics, but it must be done honestly. Since no ID scientist has demonstrated that a flagellum (to take an example--and it doesn't really matter if it's the right example) cannot have evolved, it can be presented as (at most, and very tentatively) a candidate for a design smoking gun, but it must be done so with full disclosure.

You comment, by the way, contains, in my opinion, an implied and incorrect shift of my target from where it has been (the methods of the ID movement and the incompetent leadership of the ID movement) onto where it never has been (ID proper).

Might the thought ever have entered your mind that perhaps as some wild, far-fetched outside logical possibility ID is just a little bit more than simply an apology for the Christian God?
That it might possibly be? Why yes, I’ve written many times that while it is presently not science, should ID scientists actually do something to put it on firm scientific footing I’d be delighted. If Dembski actually uses his mathematics to demonstrate design in nature, I’ll write a glorious testimony to his efforts on these pages.

Isn't it possible--just possible--that all-encompassing scientific materialism robs us of an important explanatory tool--namely agency?
Of course, by design it doesn’t invoke an agency. But naturally you are free to invoke an agent when science cannot offer an explanation. (Or even when it does.) You cannot, however, describe such activities as science. You must have read at least a couple of the gazillion times I have written that cosmological fine tuning can only be explained by parallel universes or God. But even I would agree that if parallel universes are ruled out, it doesn’t “prove” God, it strengthens the apologetic argument.

Could it be that there exist phenomena in the observable natural world which can serve as evidence for the Christian God as merely one possible candidate among perhaps many others and that one may believe this as an epistemological consequence of reasoning while at the same time believing that the Christian God is the actual perpetrator as a position of metaphysical faith without being a deceiving, conniving theocrat?
Again, have I not provided many examples of fine tuning which I believe constitute physical, scientific evidence of God’s creation? Is it hard to see that while I believe that, at the same time I recognize that my conclusion, though based on scientific evidence, is not science?

Do you honestly not find it the least bit funny or odd or incomplete that the quote explaining naturalism which you provided describes the "supernatural" as being not observable or subjectable to experimentation and yet conveniently provides no explanation of what objects are designated as supernatural?
No, I don’t. If you re-read the post, you’ll note that I do not write, anywhere, that scientific materialism is all-encompassing. I wrote: scientific materialism not a threat to Christianity, and I gave my reasons. I could have added “and in fact I think it is a very good thing, a God given endeavor.” Scientific materialism (science, if you will) is to general revelation what theology is to special revelation. And science will and does glorify God even without asserting (that the oh-so-obvious-to-us conclusion of a designer) that ID is science, ought to be taught as science, and only a conspiracy is preventing it from assuming its proper position in the science community. In cosmology I see God, and I like to tell my fellow believers and any unbelievers who care to listen why I see God. I believe that glorifies God. I don’t care at all that many people do not see God, there’s nothing I can do about that, and I don’t feel put upon that I can’t get my views into a science curriculum.

Why don't you ease up on the conspiracy mongering and try a little critical thinking for a change, huh?
I could always use more critical thinking, no argument there.

If it is the duty of a Christian to decry the apparent foolishness of his brother in Christ, then consider me your whistle blower.
I consider myself accountable to all Christians, so please continue to let me know when you think I am in error.

Monday, April 30, 2007

Bad ASA, Bad! (Not)

While I was on hiatus I see that there was a tempest in a teapot over on Uncommon Descent regarding the American Scientific Affiliation (ASA), an organization of scientists/Christians up in my neck of the woods (though way down south in Massachusetts).

Dembski is upset because the ASA has apparently (based on what Dembski wrote, I am not a member of the ASA) shifted its emphasis from a battle against "scientific materialism" to a fight against Young Earth Creationism.

Well, I'm guessing this is a case of reaping what you sow. If the ASA is less friendly to ID than it was, it is because of the direction ID took under the guidance of Dembski, Wells, and company. An organization of Christians and scientists would, in my opinion, be performing its fiduciary duty (to both camps) by distancing itself from a movement that employs deceptive tactics and a fondness for litigation. In Christianity, the ends never justify the means. Never. While Paul could be "all things to all people," he always did so honestly. Timothy was circumcised, after the Jerusalem Council (I wonder if his first response to Paul's instruction was: "but, but, but, the Council ruled..I saw the letter..), to be more acceptable to the Jews, but it was not a deception to get his foot in the door. He didn't say: "See, I'm a Jew like you, let me in your schools" just so that, once inside, he could reveal that, in spite of his previous protest to the contrary, it really was all about Christianity. There is no "wedge document" approach anywhere in scripture. May it never be.

If the ID leadership does not like the ASA's tepid support: heal thyself.

What about scientific materialism? Well, it has many definitions. I'll just use the one from Wikipedia, which redirects you to a page on Naturalism:
Definition of Methodological Naturalism

Methodological naturalism contrasted with metaphysical naturalism

Metaphysical naturalism, which is often called "philosophical naturalism" or "ontological naturalism", takes an ontological approach to naturalism. Ontology is a matter of whether something exists, and so this is the view that the supernatural does not exist, thus entailing strong atheism.

In contrast, methodological naturalism is "the adoption or assumption of philosophical naturalism within scientific method with or without fully accepting or believing it … science is not metaphysical and does not depend on the ultimate truth of any metaphysics for its success (although science does have metaphysical implications), but methodological naturalism must be adopted as a strategy or working hypothesis for science to succeed. We may therefore be agnostic about the ultimate truth of naturalism, but must nevertheless adopt it and investigate nature as if nature is all that there is."

Relationship to the supernatural

This definition rules out recourse to the supernatural. Pennock contends that as supernatural agents and powers "are above and beyond the natural world and its agents and powers" and "are not constrained by natural laws", only logical impossibilities constrain what a supernatural agent could not do, and "If we could apply natural knowledge to understand supernatural powers, then, by definition, they would not be supernatural". As the supernatural is necessarily a mystery to us, it can provide no grounds on which to judge scientific models. "Experimentation requires observation and control of the variables … But by definition we have no control over supernatural entities or forces." Allowing science to appeal to untestable supernatural powers would make the scientist's task just too easy, undermining the discipline that allows science to make progress, and "would be as profoundly unsatisfying as the ancient Greek playwright's reliance upon the deus ex machina to extract his hero from a difficult predicament."

Naturalism of this sort says nothing about the existence or nonexistence of the supernatural which by this definition is beyond natural testing. Other philosophers of science hold that some supernatural explanations might be testable in principle, but are so unlikely, given past results, that resources should not be wasted exploring them. Either way, their rejection is only a practical matter, so it is possible to be a methodological naturalist and an ontological supernaturalist at the same time. For example, while natural scientists follow methodological naturalism in their scientific work, they may also believe in God (ontological supernaturalism), or they may be metaphysical naturalists and therefore atheists. This position does not preclude knowledge that derives from the study of what is hitherto considered supernatural, but considers that if such a phenomenon can be scientifically examined and explained naturally, it then ceases to be supernatural.
(In heaven, we might ask Luke the physician if he practiced medicine in a manner consistent with this definition.)

Folks, this is not a threat to Christianity. In fact, it is a profound misunderstanding of Christianity to claim that this is a threat. A similar yet perhaps more understandable mistake would be to claim atheism as a threat to Christianity, which is utter nonsense. For one thing, the bible tells us that such people will exist, and it does not characterize them as a threat. They are fools, but not a threat.

Indeed, in a universal sense there can be no threat at all to Christianity. He who is in us is stronger than he who is in the world. His word will not return void. Christianity is not dualistic: it is not a religion that pits good versus evil. God is an infinitely powerful good. Evil, by comparison, is infinitesimal. Not only is scientific materialism not a threat, and not only is atheism not a threat, but even if the United States declared itself a secular atheistic republic that would not be a threat to Christianity. To think so is to acknowledge that the Sam Harris’s of the world can thwart the will of a sovereign God. If you fight the culture wars, do so for the glory of God, not because you are worried that God could somehow lose. If you think God might lose, go back and study the Sovereignty of God.

Any warfare in the spiritual realm is not between God and Satan (which is silly even to contemplate) but on a personal level between a Christian and demonic powers. It is not a battle to gain control of the country, it is a battle to get you, in some form or another, to deny God. Satan battled Peter (and, in that instance, won) getting him to deny Christ--Satan did not battle God or Israel. The bible doesn't ask us to fight the culture wars; it asks us to keep our personal walk in line regardless of the circumstances.

In other words, and on a more practical level, the only "threat" to Christianity comes from within. Because the only "damage" (not the right word, but you know what I mean) that one can inflict upon God is to rob him of his glory. And it is Christians, not unbelievers, who rob God of glory, by (1) cursing Him (which is what Satan tried to get Job to do—he was not after Job's soul—what would he do with it?) or (2) by not giving the gospel or by (3) behaving badly, as it were.

Denyse O'Leary asks, in a follow-up UD post: Did the premier organization of Christians in science really choose to target fellow Christians instead of materialism in science?

She then goes on to write that the answer, alas, appears to be yes. She is shocked that the ASA (Again, I am assuming they are reporting the ASA position accurately) has "turned its fire on fellow Christians."

But the right response is: In principal there is nothing wrong with that, depending on the manner in which one "targets" his brother. It is far more important for Christians to engage other Christians in a common search for God's truth (iron sharpening iron) that to engage in apologetics with atheists who, apart from divine intervention from the Holy Spirit, are predisposed to deem our arguments as foolishness. Why fight what you can't win—you cannot possibly, by force of reason, convert Richard Dawkins. (Of course, I am not saying don't give the gospel--I am saying that, to first order, only give the gospel.) But you might persuade a fellow Christian that a stance, particularly a dogmatic stand, as is often the case with Young Earth Creationists, is unbiblical.