Wednesday, December 03, 2003

Lesson 6: Millennial Blessings for the Church (Part 5)


Note: This is the last of the posts on historic premillennialism. Those of you who have the outline will know that the next topic was supposed to be Covenant Theology. However, due to time constraints we will move directly into a discussion of postmillennialism. Furthermore, I was going to teach "vanilla" postmillennialism and, at the end of the course, discuss (partial) preterism. Time compression is also causing another change: Right out of the box I will combine the two topics and teach P4: postmillennialism from a partial-preterist perspective.


The bizarre nature of the millennium

If premillennialism is true, what are the implications for the nature of the millennium? This thread of reasoning, according to critics, leads to some peculiar conclusions.

Premillennialists assert (of necessity) that births will continue during the millennium. These new generations will include unbelievers, since we know there is to be a rebellion of unbelievers at the end of the millennium.

However, these new generations cannot be the descendents of resurrected saints, because they do engage in marital relations:

At the resurrection people will neither marry nor be given in marriage; they will be like the angels in heaven. (Matt. 22:30)

The only obvious solution is the presence of unresurrected unbelievers in the millennial kingdom. However, scripture denies the possibility of normal humans (let alone unbelievers) in the kingdom:
I declare to you, brothers, that flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God, nor does the perishable inherit the imperishable. (1 Cor. 15:20)

More to the point, evil is excluded:
41The Son of Man will send out his angels, and they will weed out of his kingdom everything that causes sin and all who do evil. 42They will throw them into the fiery furnace, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. 43Then the righteous will shine like the sun in the kingdom of their Father. He who has ears, let him hear. (Matt. 13:41-43)

So again, the question is, where do these wicked who are to participate in the rebellion come from? According to Revelation 20, Satan, when released, deceives the nations, but these nations were already judged in Revelation 19:
From His mouth comes a sharp sword, so that with it He may strike down the nations, and He will rule them with a rod of iron; and He treads the wine press of the fierce wrath of God, the Almighty. (Rev. 19:5)

The rebellion is ended by fire. (Rev 20:9). Who are these mysterious people who are deceived, rebel, and are destroyed by fire?

According to premillennialism, one group present during the millennium is the redeemed, raised from the dead and glorified. It is inconceivable that they are deceived. Nor can they generate deceivers, being of the resurrection. Therefore, it must be that there were present at the Second Coming normal humans who were not raised, glorified, or judged. They simply lived through the second coming. It must be this group that propagates the species.

This leads to the rather bizarre situation of the coexistence of resurrected saints, normal (sinful) humans, and Jesus Christ. Scripture does not mention such a possibility.

It is strangely reminiscent of the movie Alien Nation. Here you are a normal flesh and blood human, sinning, procreating, ailing, and aging (albeit, it would appear, to reduced degrees). Your next door neighbor has a glorified imperishable body. I wonder who has the nicer lawn.

How do some escape the judgment of the Second Coming? Consider that:
  • The righteous dead are raised

  • The righteous living meet Christ in the air and are also changed (1 Cor. 15: 50-55)

  • The wicked will be taken away (but not resurrected):

    37 But as the days of Noah were, so also will the coming of the Son of Man be. 38 For as in the days before the flood, they were eating and drinking, marrying and giving in marriage until the day Noah entered the arc, 39 and did not know until the flood came and took them all away, so also will the coming of the Son of Man be. (Matt. 24:37-39)

Premillennialism, according to its critics, offers no good explanation for the identity of those who escape.


To summarize the problem:
  • The millennium begins with only the redeemed. The wicked, though not resurrected, are taken away (Matt. 24:39)

  • In fact, there should not be any normal humans period, including believers (1 Cor. 15:20).

  • In spite of this, there are born new, normal humans, ultimately from which a rebellion, led by Satan, is launched.

  • There is no credible explanation for where these people come from.

Amillennialist Kim Riddleberger puts it this way:
Therefore the apparent strength of premillennialism is actually its biggest weakness. If premillennialists are correct about their reading of Rev. 20, Jesus rules upon the earth over people in resurrected and unresurrected bodies during the millennial age. Our Lord's millennial age will end with a massive satanic deception of the nations and a revolt against Christ and His church after they have reigned on earth for a thousand years. If true, this millennial apostasy is tantamount to a second fall. 133

Another amillennialist Anthony Hoekema summarizes for many the discomfort with the premillennialist's millennium:

Why, for example, should believers be raised from the dead to live on an earth which is not yet glorified and which is still groaning because of the presence sin, rebellion, and death (Rom. 8:19-22)? Why should the glorified Christ have to come back to earth to rule over his enemies with a rod of iron and thus still have to endure opposition to his sovereignty? Was not this phase of His work completed during His humiliation? Is Christ not coming back in the fullness of glory to usher in, not an interim period of qualified peace and blessing, but the final state of unqualified perfection? 134

On that note, we end our discussion of historic premillennialism.

133 Riddleberger, Amillennialism, p. 233.
134 Anthony Hoekema, "Historic Premillennialism, an Amillennial Response", in Meaning of the Millennium, p. 59.

Tuesday, December 02, 2003

The New Moneychangers

Still "Mr. Mom"-ing for another week until my wife gets back from Taiwan.

Found this interesting quote about Christian Bookstores:
My guess is that in the current Christian bookstore the simplistic books outweigh the simple books by at least 10 to 1. I've often wondered where Jesus would apply His hastily made whip if He were to visit our culture. My guess is that it would not be money-changing tables in the temple that would feel His wrath, but the display racks in Christian bookstores. -- R.C. Sproul, Lifeviews, (Revell 1986), p. 184.

Sproul was lamenting the lack of interest in doctrine, and the inordinate interest in "easy steps" instruction.

Monday, December 01, 2003

Lesson 6: Millennial Blessings for the Church (Part 4)

Critique of Historic Premillennialism

The strength of premillennialism is in its straightforward understanding of Revelation 19 as describing the Second Coming, and Revelation 20 as depicting an earthly millennium.

Critics contend that this simplistic, literal interpretation, attractive as it may be, is (a) contradicted by simpler, non-symbolic scripture elsewhere; and (b) leads to an untenable, bizarre situation in the millennium: the earth is populated (indeed repopulated) by normal human beings living alongside resurrected saints in glorified bodies, living saints who were caught up in the air when Christ returned, and Christ Himself. Nowhere in scripture does it teach of such an eclectic mix coexisting.

And it gets worse. In this peculiar citizenry we still find evil, sin and death. And from these kingdom inhabitants, a rebellion will arise. (Rev 20:9).

Problems, as we shall see, abound. Just for starters, in the millennium passage of Revelation 20 we read:
I saw thrones on which were seated those who had been given authority to judge. And I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded because of their testimony for Jesus and because of the word of God. They had not worshiped the beast or his image and had not received his mark on their foreheads or their hands. They came to life and reigned with Christ a thousand years. (Rev. 20:4)

The millennium passage, the pride and joy of premillennialists of all stripes, when viewed closely, only talks of resurrected saints (actually, it can be argued that it does not even explicitly mention resurrected) as being part of the millennium.

Now it cannot be that that there are only resurrected saints in the premillennialist’s millennium, because nobody, absolutely nobody believes that saints in resurrected bodies are deceived by Satan and participate in the final rebellion.

We will come back to this point (tomorrow). For now, we move to more mundane criticisms.


The nature and timing of the kingdom

Premillennialism naturally views the kingdom of God as awaiting the millennium for its consummation. Yet critics argue that scripture teaches the kingdom is not future and physical but rather spiritual and present.
And I confer on you a kingdom, just as my Father conferred one on me, (Luke 22:29)

20Once, having been asked by the Pharisees when the kingdom of God would come, Jesus replied, "The kingdom of God does not come with your careful observation, 21nor will people say, 'Here it is,' or 'There it is,' because the kingdom of God is within you." (Luke 17:20-21)

Jesus said, "My kingdom is not of this world. If it were, my servants would fight to prevent my arrest by the Jews. But now my kingdom is from another place." (John 18:36)

These and other passages do not point a future physical kingdom but a present spiritual kingdom inaugurated by Christ during his ministry. This is what John the Baptist spoke of:
In those days, John the Baptist came preaching in the wilderness of Judea, and saying “Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand”. (Matt. 3:1-2)


The duration of the kingdom


Premillennialists view the future kingdom as finite. It lasts a given time (most say 1000 years) and afterwards we enter the eternal state. Critics argue that the kingdom has no end:
32He will be great and will be called the Son of the Most High. The Lord God will give him the throne of his father David, 33and he will reign over the house of Jacob forever; ." (Luke 1:32-33)


The two resurrectionshis kingdom will never end


As we discussed, premillennialists expect two resurrections based on their reading of Rev. 20. One (the righteous) occurs at the beginning; the other (of the wicked) at the end. Much scripture, however, depicts a single general resurrection at the time of Christ’s return:


Do not be amazed at this, for a time is coming when all who are in their graves will hear his voice 29and come out--those who have done good will rise to live, and those who have done evil will rise to be condemned. (John 5:28-29)


Furthermore, they will face a single, comprehensive judgment at His coming:
31"When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, he will sit on his throne in heavenly glory. 32All the nations will be gathered before him, and he will separate the people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats. 33He will put the sheep on his right and the goats on his left. (Matt. 25:31-33)

they will go away to eternal punishment, but the righteous to eternal life." (Matt. 25:46)

The wicked will be judged at the Second Coming, not 1000 years later:
9They will be punished with everlasting destruction and shut out from the presence of the Lord and from the majesty of his power 10on the day he comes to be glorified in his holy people and to be marveled at among all those who have believed. This includes you, because you believed our testimony to you. (2 Th. 1:9-10)


The final enemy


According to the Apostle Paul, the final enemy of Christ is death, and death is defeated at the resurrection of the righteous:
25For he must reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet. 26The last enemy to be destroyed is death. (1 Cor. 15:25-26)

50I declare to you, brothers, that flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God, nor does the perishable inherit the imperishable. 51Listen, I tell you a mystery: We will not all sleep, but we will all be changed-- 52in a flash, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet. For the trumpet will sound, the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed. 53For the perishable must clothe itself with the imperishable, and the mortal with immortality. 54When the perishable has been clothed with the imperishable, and the mortal with immortality, then the saying that is written will come true: "Death has been swallowed up in victory." 55"Where, O death, is your victory? Where, O death, is your sting?" (1 Cor. 15: 50-55)

According to premillennialism, the final enemy of Christ is Satan, and he is defeated 1000 years after the resurrection of the righteous. Many premillennialists acknowledge that death is the true final enemy, and are forced to argue that in spite of 1 Cor. 15, death is not actually defeated until the end of the millennium.

Friday, November 28, 2003

Lesson 6: Millennial Blessings for the Church (Part 3)

More Support for Two Resurrections


In addition to the passage in Revelation 20, historic premillennialists find additional support for two bodily resurrections in other scripture131. A literal translation of Phi. 3:11 (and so, somehow, to attain to the resurrection from the dead) speaks of "Out-resurrection from the dead ones". This is taken to indicate that Paul viewed the resurrection of the righteous to be separate from that of the wicked.

Similarly:
those who are considered worthy of taking part in that age and in the resurrection from the dead will neither marry nor be given in marriage, (Luke 10:35)

can be understood as implying a separate resurrection for the righteous. (Keep this passage in mind: the fact that the resurrected will neither marry nor be given in marriage will prove problematic for premillennialism when we, in the next section, critique the viewpoint.)

Other passages a partial resurrection or a resurrection of just the righteous:
For the Lord himself will come down from heaven, with a loud command, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet call of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. (1 Th. 4:16)

and you will be blessed. Although they cannot repay you, you will be repaid at the resurrection of the righteous." (Luke 14:14)

while others permit one to infer (or not, depending on how you choose to read them) a two stage resurrection:
Multitudes who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake: some to everlasting life, others to shame and everlasting contempt. (Dan. 12:2)

and come out--those who have done good will rise to live, and those who have done evil will rise to be condemned. (John 5:29)

A very important passage is one we have discussed:
23But each in his own turn: Christ, the firstfruits; then, when he comes, those who belong to him. 24Then the end will come, when he hands over the kingdom to God the Father after he has destroyed all dominion, authority and power. 25For he must reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet. 26The last enemy to be destroyed is death. (1 Cor. 15:23-26)

As we wrote earlier, the "firstfruits" is the resurrection of Jesus Christ. The first human resurrection, of the righteous (his own) is at the end of v.23. Then there is an all important word at the beginning of v. 24: "Then". To premillennialists, this implies an "interregnum" between the resurrection of the righteous and when "the end" will come131. This period of delay is taken to be the millennium.

Another line of reasoning for two, separated resurrections involves passages like this:
1If any of you has a dispute with another, dare he take it before the ungodly for judgment instead of before the saints? 2Do you not know that the saints will judge the world? And if you are to judge the world, are you not competent to judge trivial cases? 3Do you not know that we will judge angels? How much more the things of this life! (1 Cor. 1:3)

The argument is made:
  1. The righteous will act as judges of the wicked.

  2. Therefore, in order for the righteous to assume their duties as judges, there is logically an interval between the two resurrections.

Biblical Support Favoring Historic over Dispensational Premillennialism

Historic premillennialists argue for a strict literalistic interpretation of Revelation 20. However, they disagree with dispensationalists when it comes to Old Testament prophecy concerning Israel. They spiritualize much Old Testament prophecy and subsume the bulk of it into the New Testament church.

For example, they argue that the prophecies concerning the first advent were not fulfilled literally. Other, quite famous Messianic prophecy, such as:
"When Israel was a child, I loved him, and out of Egypt I called my son. (Hosea 11:1)

were, in their original context , not viewed as Messianic at all, but as a reference to the Exodus. Only through New Testament interpretation and in some sense reuse of the passage:
where he stayed until the death of Herod. And so was fulfilled what the Lord had said through the prophet: "Out of Egypt I called my son." (Matt. 2:15)

do we see the real meaning, or perhaps the new meaning.

Ladd summarizes this difference in a scathing comment:
Dispensationalism forms its eschatology by a literal interpretation of the Old Testament and then fits the New Testament to it. A nondispensational eschatology forms its theology from the explicit teaching of the New Testament. 132

Next we turn to a critique of historic premillennialism.


130 Grenz, The Millennial Maze, p. 135.
131 Ladd, Crucial Questions about the Kingdom of God, pp. 178-179.
132 George E. Ladd, "Historic Premillennialism", in The Meaning of the Millennium: Four Views, Robert Clouse, ed., (Intervarsity) 1977, p. 27

Tuesday, November 25, 2003

Lesson 6: Millennial Blessings for the Church (Part 2)

Biblical Support for Historic Premillennialism

A distinctive feature of historic premillennialism is the post-tribulation rapture. The church will be present on earth during the tribulation.

Expectation of a post-tribulation rapture arises from scripture than indicates that the typical experience of the saints will be, in fact, tribulation:125
"I have told you these things, so that in me you may have peace. In this world you will have trouble. But take heart! I have overcome the world." (John 16:33)

strengthening the disciples and encouraging them to remain true to the faith. "We must go through many hardships to enter the kingdom of God," they said. (Acts 14:22)

Not only so, but we also rejoice in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance; (Rom 5:3)

so that no one would be unsettled by these trials. You know quite well that we were destined for them. (1 Th. 3:3)

18Dear children, this is the last hour; and as you have heard that the antichrist is coming, even now many antichrists have come. This is how we know it is the last hour.
22Who is the liar? It is the man who denies that Jesus is the Christ. Such a man is the antichrist--he denies the Father and the Son.
(1 John 2:18,22)

but every spirit that does not acknowledge Jesus is not from God. This is the spirit of the antichrist, which you have heard is coming and even now is already in the world. (1 John 4:3)

I, John, your brother and companion in the suffering and kingdom and patient endurance that are ours in Jesus, was on the island of Patmos because of the word of God and the testimony of Jesus. (Rev. 1:9).

It must be noted that the trials that the saints will endure do not include experiencing God’s "wrath", a fate reserved for the wicked. The saints will endure sufferings and persecution during the tribulation, but will be spared from wrath:
Since you have kept my command to endure patiently, I will also keep you from the hour
of trial that is going to come upon the whole world to test those who live on the earth.
(Rev 3:10)

The belief that the rapture occurs after the tribulation is also supported, according to historic premillennialists, by New Testament descriptions of the return of Christ. One of the Greek words used, parousia, is exceptionally vivid. It is best translated as presence and denotes the coming of Christ to be present with his people. (For dispensationalists, at the Second Coming Christ will already have been present with His people for seven years. There, according to historic premillennialists, it makes little sense to use the word parousia.)

Furthermore, they point out that the Parousia, which is the object of their blessed hope: 126
For what is our hope, our joy, or the crown in which we will glory in the presence of our Lord Jesus when he comes? Is it not you? (1 Th. 2:19)

May he strengthen your hearts so that you will be blameless and holy in the presence of our God and Father when our Lord Jesus comes with all his holy ones. (1 Th. 3:13)

7Be patient, then, brothers, until the Lord's coming. See how the farmer waits for the land to yield its valuable crop and how patient he is for the autumn and spring rains. 8You too, be patient and stand firm, because the Lord's coming is near. (James 5:7-8)

And now, dear children, continue in him, so that when he appears we may be confident and unashamed before him at his coming. (1 John 2:28)

is consistently presented as occurring after the tribulation, as in the Olivet discourse (Matt. 24) and other scripture, e.g.,
And then the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord Jesus will overthrow with the
breath of his mouth and destroy by the splendor of his coming.
(2. Th. 2:8)

Post-tribulationist Douglas Moo asserts: 127
A study of the vocabulary employed in describing the return of Christ paints a uniform picture: believers are exhorted to look for and live in the light of this glorious event. And while some texts [scripture] obviously place this coming after the Tribulation, there are none which equally obviously place it before the Tribulation.

To add teeth to what Moo asserts, historic premillennialists argue on two fronts. The first is that the principal rapture passages:
And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come back and take you to be with me that you also may be where I am. (John 14:3)

51Listen, I tell you a mystery: We will not all sleep, but we will all be changed-- 52in a flash, in the twinkling of an eye, at the last trumpet. For the trumpet will sound, the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed. (1 Cor. 15:51-52)

13Brothers, we do not want you to be ignorant about those who fall asleep, or to grieve like the rest of men, who have no hope. 14We believe that Jesus died and rose again and so we believe that God will bring with Jesus those who have fallen asleep in him. 15According to the Lord's own word, we tell you that we who are still alive, who are left till the coming of the Lord, will certainly not precede those who have fallen asleep. 16For the Lord himself will come down from heaven, with a loud command, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet call of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. 17After that, we who are still alive and are left will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air. And so we will be with the Lord forever. (1 Th. 4:13-17)

do not indicate that this event should be separated from Christ’s Second Coming. Rather they favor placing the rapture (a) post-tribulation; and (b) simultaneous with the Second Coming. The other front is passages such as 1 Th. 5:1-11; 2 Th. 1-2, along with the Olivet Discourse, and the book of Revelation which positively teach the post-tribulation position. 128


So, in a nutshell, this line of reasoning is:
  • Scripture tells us to live for and look for the Parousia (Second Coming)

  • Therefore we (the body of believers) are around at the Second Coming

  • At the Second Coming, Christ defeats the antichrist, ending the tribulation

  • Therefore we (the body of believers) went through the tribulation

  • Those alive are post-tribulation raptured at this time (Christ’s return)


Dispensationalists teach that after the secret rapture, the saints are taken to enjoy the Marriage Supper of the Lamb. Historic premillennialists have different expectation: The raptured saints meet Christ in the air and then immediately return with him. The imagery is of a welcoming party: subjects leaving the city to meet their king as he returns from a journey or battle, and to escort him back into the city. Similar imagery is used in the parable of the ten virgins, when the (wise) virgins meet the bridegroom and escort him back into the wedding feast. Another example is found in the book of Acts:
15The brothers there had heard that we were coming, and they traveled as far as the Forum of Appius and the Three Taverns to meet us. At the sight of these men Paul thanked God and was encouraged. 16When we got to Rome, Paul was allowed to live by himself, with a soldier to guard him. (Acts 28:15-16)

Believers went from Rome to the outlying town of Three Taverns and escorted him back into Rome.

The basis of the premillennial timeline

When it comes to the basic support for a premillennial timeline, i.e. that after Christ returns there will be an earthly millennium, historic premillennialists turn to the same scripture as dispensationalists: Revelation 19-22.

The rider of the white horse, in Rev. 19:11-16, signifies Christ’s return to destroy his enemies. Moving on to Rev. 20 we have the 1000 year passage, which indicates that Satan is (a) bound at the start of the 1000 years; and (b) released at the end of 1000 years for some final mischief.

Central to any premillennial view are the two resurrections in Revelation 20:

4I saw thrones on which were seated those who had been given authority to judge. And I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded because of their testimony for Jesus and because of the word of God. They had not worshiped the beast or his image and had not received his mark on their foreheads or their hands. They came to life and reigned with Christ a thousand years. 5(The rest of the dead did not come to life until the thousand years were ended.) This is the first resurrection. (Rev 20:4-5)

According to Ladd, any interpretation which tries to make the first resurrection spiritual while the only the second is physical does violence to the text:

At the beginning of the millennial period, part of the dead come to life. At its conclusion, the rest of the dead come to life. 129


To premillennialists, it's as simple as that.


125 Grenz, The Millennial Maze, pp. 131-132
126 Ibid., p. 132.
127 Douglas J. Moo, "The Posttribulation Rapture Position", in , The Rapture: Pre-, Mid-, or Post-tribulational?(Zondervan), 1984. pp. 177-178.
128 Grenz, The Millennial Maze, p. 133.
129 George E. Ladd, Crucial Questions about the Kingdom of God, (Eerdmans), 1952, p. 146.

Monday, November 24, 2003

Lesson 6: Millennial Blessings for the Church

We now turn our attention to what may be the oldest view of the end-times: historic premillennialism.

Historic premillennialism claims many early church fathers among its adherents, including Irenaeus118 [140-203], Justin Martyr119 [100-165], and Papias [80-155].

In modern times, the most noted proponents of Historic Premillennialism include George Eldon Ladd of the Fuller Theological Seminary, who has written such books as A Theology of the New Testament, "Historic Premillennialism" and The Blessed Hope (in which he critiques dispensationalism), and James Boice of The Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals.

Review of the features of Historic Premillennialism

Historic premillennialism teaches that the first coming of Christ is the beginning of a new age and the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecy. In his book on Amillennialism120, Kim Riddleberger gives this summary of historic premillennialism:
When Jesus begins his public ministry [during the first coming, i.e., two millennia ago], the kingdom of God is manifest through his preaching, teaching, and miracles, though the kingdom is not yet consummated. Upon Jesus’ ascension into heaven and the outpouring of the Spirit at Pentecost, the kingdom remains present through the Spirit and advances until the end of the age, which is marked by the return of Christ to the earth in judgment. Great apostasy and tribulation occur immediately preceding the return of Christ. After his return, a period of a thousand years121 (the millennium) will separate the first resurrection from the second resurrection. Satan will be bound and the kingdom will be consummated. At the end of the millennium period, Satan will be loosed, and a massive rebellion led by the mysterious Gog and Magog will immediately precede the second resurrection or final judgment. After this 1000 year earthly millennium, God will create a new heaven and a new earth.


The basic features of historic premillennialism are: 122

  • The New Testament church is the initial phase of Christ’s Kingdom, as prophesied by the Old Testament prophets. 123

  • The church may win occasional victories in history (including evangelization of the nations), but ultimately she will fail in her mission, lose influence, and become corrupted as worldwide evil increases toward the end of the church age. There will be an appearance of a personal antichrist.

  • The church will pass through a future, worldwide, unprecedented time of travail (the Great Tribulation), which will punctuate the end of contemporary history.

  • Rather than as a result of gradual progress, the onset of the millennium is cataclysmic. It will be visible to the entire earth.

  • Christ will return at the end of the tribulation to rapture the church, resurrect dead saints, and conduct the judgment of the righteous. This is the most significant difference in outward features between historic premillennialism and dispensationalism: for historic premillennialists, the rapture is post-tribulation.

  • Christ will then descend to earth with His glorified saints, fight the battle of Armageddon, defeat the antichrist, bind Satan, and establish a worldwide political kingdom which will be personally administered by him in Jerusalem for 1000 years. Many Jews will repent and accept Christ as the Messiah. The millennium will be a time of peace, justice, and extreme blessings: the desert will boom as a rose. There will be a cessation of hostilities among the animals (Is. 11:8-9, 65:25). However, it is not the eternal state; in particular there is still sin and death. Evil will be greatly retrained, and unbelieving nations are kept in check and ruled by Christ with an iron rod.

  • At the end of 1000 years, Satan will be loosed and a fierce rebellion will ensue (sometimes identified as the Gog-Magog war). God will intervene with fiery judgments to rescue Christ and the saints. The resurrection and judgment of the wicked will occur and the eternal state will begin.



While it is tempting to conclude that historic premillennialism differs from dispensationalism only in the timing of the rapture, such a conclusion is quite wrong. For underneath the hood, the differences are vast. Historic premillennialism completely rejects the dispensational view of redemptive history. The only aspect of similarity is that both views are premillennial.

A table listing some of the differences between Historic Premillennialism and dispensationalism may be helpful:


Historic PremillennialismDispensationalism
AdventEarly church19th Century
RapturePost-tribulationPre-tribulation
TribulationUnspecified duration (maybe 7 years)—includes church7 years, no church
MillenniumSpiritually oriented kingdom—the purpose is a higher outworking of Christ’s prerogatives as Lord. Jewish theocracy—the purpose is to complete God's redemptive plan for the Jews.
ChurchSpiritual Israel, covenantal relationships with God have passed over, some promises to Abraham are fulfilled therein.A separate body of believers, does not inherit covenantal relationship or Abraham's promises.
Blessed HopeVisible second comingSecret rapture
Kingdom OfferSpiritual kingdom instituted in the hearts of believers.Rejected by Jews necessitating the church age intercalation.
Hermeneutic (for prophecy)Mostly spiritualMostly literal



Two Resurrections

The linchpin of premillennialism is two resurrections124. The first resurrection occurs when Christ returns. The righteous of all ages will rise to partake in the millennial kingdom. After the millennium the rest of the dead are raised and the wicked will be judged and consigned to their eternal misery.

The higher outworking of Christ’s Prerogatives

For historic premillennialists, the millennium represents the next step in Christ’s role as Lord. After His resurrection he sat at the right hand of the Father. His triumph, however, is not complete:

For he must reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet. (1 Cor. 15:25)

Also, in the present age, his reign is visible only to the faithful. In the millennium, Christ’s Lordship will be public and evident to all. All knees will bow, all tongues will confess:

10that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father. (Phil. 2:10-11)

Next we will examine the biblical support for historic premillennialism.



118 Irenaeus was a disciple of Polycarp who was a disciple of John. Yes, that John.
119 From whom, of course, we get the word martyr. Here is an authenticated account of his martyrdom from The Catholic Encyclopedia: "The Prefect Rusticus says: Approach and sacrifice, all of you, to the gods. Justin says: No one in his right mind gives up piety for impiety. The Prefect Rusticus says: If you do not obey, you will be tortured without mercy. Justin replies: That is our desire, to be tortured for Our Lord, Jesus Christ, and so to be saved, for that will give us salvation and firm confidence at the more terrible universal tribunal of Our Lord and Savior. And all the martyrs said: Do as you wish; for we are Christians, and we do not sacrifice to idols. The Prefect Rusticus read the sentence: Those who do not wish to sacrifice to the gods and to obey the emperor will be scourged and beheaded according to the laws. The holy martyrs glorifying God betook themselves to the customary place, where they were beheaded and consummated their martyrdom confessing their Saviour."
120 Kim Riddleberger, A Case for Amillennialism, (Baker Books), 2003, p. 28.
121 Actually, historic premillennialists are not as adamant as dispensationalists that the duration be precisely 1000 years.
122 Based upon: Kenneth Gentry, as quoted in Sproul, The Last Days According to Jesus, pp. 199-200.
123 This is in vivid conflict with dispensationalism, which holds that the present church age was unforeseen by the Old Testament prophets.
124 Millard Erickson, Contemporary Options in Eschatology: a Study of the Millennium, (Baker), 1977. p. 97.


Thursday, November 20, 2003

WeIRd

Weird. Somehow part (the bottom 1/3) of the following post was lost in the aether. It has been recovered.

Not sure what posting will be like over the next three weeks. My wife is off to Taiwan to visit her family. Me and the boys have been left behind. So being Mr. Mom will dig into the blogging time. I know the day before she returns, the extensive search and destroy mission for discarded pizza boxes will take priority. Woe, woe, woe to me if she finds one under the sofa.

What Wright says that "Saint Paul Really Said"

Been rereading two books for two different studies. One is, for the gazillionth time, R.C. Sproul's Chosen by God. The other is N. T. Wright's What Saint Paul Really Said.

These books couldn't be more different.

The two authors, each with impressive credentials, couldn't be more different.

Sproul approaches his subject (predestination) with humility. His style is: here is what is written in scripture and, logically, this is what it must mean.

That is not Wright's approach to his subject, which is the theology of Paul. (The punch line being that Luther misinterpreted Paul, because he did not understand 1st century Judaism, a deficiency that resulted in a serious error: an undue emphasis on, and a faulty understanding of, justification.) His approach, seemingly adopted by his followers, would never be accused of being humble or charitable. And while scripture is referred to, a great deal of Wright’s conclusion are based on historic arguments and reckless speculation, presented as fact, about what Paul was thinking, before and after his conversion.

This of course means nothing in terms of which writer is correct. In fact, their subject matters are sufficiently (but not perfectly) orthogonal that both could be essentially right, or both wrong, or one of each.

In my opinion, it is the latter. Sproul hits a homerun in his introduction to predestination. His book is, in my view, a classic. Wright’s book is, on the other hand, so flawed as to almost take my breath away.

That is the last I will mention Sproul. I just felt like contrasting them since I am currently studying both.

Criticizing Wright is not for the thin skinned. He has amassed a following that surpasses, in its zeal, Doug Wilson's acolytes, another camp of which I have, in the past, run afoul. Challenge Wright and you are likely to be called dimwitted, anachronistic, and, my personal favorite, prone to worshipping a dead white man (that would be Martin Luther).

This will not be a comprehensive review of Wright's book. I will get to that sometime, probably after my Sunday school class ends. I am taking notes as I once again go through What Saint Paul Really Said in anticipation of just such a review. This is just a broadside.

Wright's arrogance astounds me. He writes of his lonely journey toward the pinnacle of Pauline scholarship:

I still have the sense of being only half-way up the mountain, of there being yet more to explore, more vistas to glimpse. Often (not always) when I read what other scholars say about Paul, I have the feeling of looking downwards into the mist, rather than upwards to the mountain top. (What Saint Paul Really Said, p. 7.)

I have not read any reviews of Wright's book, critical or favorable. I would be amazed if I am the only critic to point out what appears to be the biggest flaw: Wright elevates the importance of Paul's historic context far beyond what he should, given the fact that we are dealing with inspired scripture.

If Wright were examining uninspired writing such as 1 Clement, or even non-canonical Pauline writings, if ever discovered, then his approach would be legitimate. But when dealing with inspired scripture, historic context, while it can be illuminating, must always be a secondary consideration.

Wright treats Paul's letters as, well, Paul's letters. He does not give enough weight to the fact that they are actually God's letters.

Wright says that we cannot understand what Paul really meant unless we put it in the context of an accurate representation of 1st century Judiasm.

I say that the Holy Spirit has inspired scripture that we can understand without such knowledge, although it might be helpful. The Holy Spirit did not inspire scripture that awaited 20th century studies of 1st century Judaism before it could be correctly understood.

That's my opinion. I cannot prove it.

I’ll say again, historic knowledge is not irrelevant. But it cannot be critical. Here is an example. In Romans, Paul writes: What a wretched man I am! Who will rescue me from this body of death? (Rom. 7:24). Now that can be understood as it stands. Nevertheless, if we know that Paul is alluding to the gruesome practice of chaining the corpse of a murder victim to the murderer, then the verse is further illuminated. However, that knowledge is not required in order to understand the gist of what Paul is teaching.

Furthermore, while Wright is no doubt correct that our knowledge of 1st century Judiasm has grown, there is no guarantee whatsoever that we have a correct, let alone a comprehensive, understanding. There exists the very real possibility—perhaps even a probability—that our supposedly lofty understanding of 1st century Judaism will undergo radical changes over the decades to come.

Imagine 2000 years from now as archeologists try to piece together Wright's theology. Suppose all they know is that he was a Protestant. No literature from the era survived. Then, amazingly, a Scofield bible is uncovered. And a complete set of Left Behind books. Imagine what incorrect inferences about Wright's theology would likely be made from that "incredible development in the understanding of 20th century Christianity". That is the situation with Paul, but Wright argues as if he knows what Saul/Paul was thinking.

Wright often talks about Pauline theology. This is representative of his error. Whatever Paul's theology was is irrelevant. What Paul wrote in his epistles, due to its inspiration, was not Paul's theology but God's theology.

Wright also writes:
The dislocation of biblical studies from theology, particularly in many North American institutions (where the majority of contemporary biblical studies takes place) has meant that Paul is often studied by people who are not trained either philosophically or theologically, and who indeed resent that such training should be necessary. (What Saint Paul Really Said, p. 21.)

Notice how he elevates not just theology but philosophy as a required discipline in order to study Paul. Wright is qualified to study Paul. Jonathan Edwards—sorry no.

Wright goes on:
Some still use him [Paul] to legitimate an old-style 'preaching of the gospel' in which the basic problem is human sin and pride and the basic answer is the cross of Christ. Others, without wishing to deny this as part of the Pauline message, are struggling to do justice to the wider categories and the larger questions that seem to be a non-negotiable part of Paul’s whole teaching. This, indeed, is the category into which I would put myself, as the present work will make clear. (What Saint Paul Really Said, p. 22.)

I think I will not bother to comment on that quote.

Wright repeatedly makes unsubstantiated claims about what Saul/Paul believed and what he thought. For example, he wrote:
But Saul of Tarsus was not interested in a timeless system of salvation, whether works-righteousness or anything else. Nor was he interested in understanding and operating a system of religion, a system of 'getting in' and/or 'staying in' (Sanders’ categories).(What Saint Paul Really Said, p. 32.)

This is pure speculation and one could argue not even very informed speculation. It is, however, convenient speculation given that it assumes what he wants to postulate: that Paul never criticized the Jews for works-based salvation. He then compounds his error by wrongly assuming that his guesses actually matter. Even if by spectacular luck he is right about what Paul thought, as I said before, it was not Paul's theology that was penned under divine inspiration. Nor was it writings that were unduly influenced by Paul's background.

No matter how much our knowledge of Paul's particular Pharisaic type increases, it is foolishness to overestimate what this implies about what Saul/Paul thought. We know a great deal more about, say, the twenty first century PCA beliefs than we do about 1st century Judaism. Yet that knowledge permits permits only educated guesses about what a particular member of a PCA congregation believes.

If Wright, as a historian, wants to theorize about Saul's/Paul's personal beliefs and personal theology, then he is correct in his assumption that a better understanding of 1st century Judaism is essential. To understand what Paul wrote in the book of Romans is another matter altogether. Whatever Paul wrote in Romans is correct, if necessary, in spite of Paul’s personal theology. And it is understandable to believers without advanced degrees. To assume otherwise is to underestimate the Holy Spirit. It puts Him at the mercy of doctrinal errors of the human writers (actually, transcribers) of scripture and denies the Creator of the Universe of the ability to formulate scripture that is understandable to His people apart from an almost Gnostic insight of an elite class, be it a Magisterium or those with Ph.D.'s in Philosophy from accredited universities.

Wednesday, November 19, 2003

Last Of The series

[Just a touch up that finishes the lesson on dispensational premillennialism. I'll be moving on to historic premillennialism.]

Absence of the word "church" in Revelation 4-22.

The absence of the word "church" in the chapters from Revelation, from chapters 4-19, chapters that dispensationalists say describe the tribulation, is another reason that they claim the church must be raptured. Mathison argues that by the same reasoning the church must not be in heaven, because the word "church" does not appear in Rev. 20-22 when heaven is being described. Also, Israel must be raptured during the tribulation, for the word Israel does not appear after Rev. 7:4 through the end of tribulation discussion.

Coming with his saints, coming for his saints

Dispensationalists argue that a separation between the rapture and the second coming is required because scripture talks about Christ coming for His saints (the rapture) and with His saints (the Second Coming).

In reality, however, this poses no problem. Looking at the "rapture" passage:
14We believe that Jesus died and rose again and so we believe that God will bring with Jesus those who have fallen asleep in him. 15According to the Lord's own word, we tell you that we who are still alive, who are left till the coming of the Lord, will certainly not precede those who have fallen asleep. 16For the Lord himself will come down from heaven, with a loud command, with the voice of the archangel and with the trumpet call of God, and the dead in Christ will rise first. 17After that, we who are still alive and are left will be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air. And so we will be with the Lord forever. (1 Th. 4:14-17)

The "with" and the "for", according to non-dispensationalists, do indeed happen at the same time. In v. 14, we read that Christ will come with those saints (their spirits) who have fallen asleep (died). In v. 16 these dead saints have their bodies resurrected. And in v. 17, He comes for those who are alive and remain. It is indeed the rapture, but it occurs at the visible Second Coming.

Monday, November 17, 2003

Lesson 5: A Future Kingdom for Israel (Part 10)

Will the church escape the tribulation?


As for passages that seem to indicate that the church is spared the tribulation. Let's look at the "escape the wrath" genre:
Since we have now been justified by his blood, how much more shall we be saved from God's wrath through him! (Rom. 5:9)

For God did not appoint us to suffer wrath but to receive salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ. (1 Th 5:9)

and to wait for his Son from heaven, whom he raised from the dead--Jesus, who rescues us from the coming wrath. (1 Th 1:10)

Since you have kept my command to endure patiently, I will also keep you from the hour of trial that is going to come upon the whole world to test those who live on the earth. (Rev. 3:10)

Rom. 5:9 surely says those who are justified by his blood are saved from God's wrath. But there is no reason to conclude it is his finite seven year tribulational wrath that is withheld from the justified, but rather his eternal wrath reserved for the damned.

Similarly regarding 1 Th. 5:9. The simplest interpretation is that we are saved from eternal damnation, not merely a seven year tribulation, by the finished work of Christ.

1 Th 1:10 is more problematic. But not in a way that helps dispensationalism. It has a certain "near term" aspect to it. One interpretation notes that the subject of the wrath is identified in the next chapter:
in their effort to keep us from speaking to the Gentiles so that they may be saved. In this way they always heap up their sins to the limit. The wrath of God has come upon them at last. (1 Th. 2:16)

That is, it is the Jews that are under wrath, a wrath that will climax very soon in the utter destruction of Jerusalem, the temple, and the scattering of those Jews who survive. Like the Hebrews during the plagues of Egypt, Paul is assuring believers that they will escape this wrath. We will look at this much more in a few lessons.

Rev. 3:10 is perhaps the most important verse, according to dispensationalists, that supports a pretribulation rapture.

Mathison argues116 that there are several questions dispensationalists need to answer regarding this interpretation:

  1. Where in this verse does Christ promise to remove the entire church from the earth?

  2. Where does it say that this verse refers to the end of the world?

  3. Doesn’t it describe a period of testing that, according to other verses in Revelation, was about to come? For example:
    Blessed is the one who reads the words of this prophecy, and blessed are those who hear it and take to heart what is written in it, because the time is near. (Rev 1:3)

    10Since you have kept my command to endure patiently, I will also keep you from the hour of trial that is going to come upon the whole world to test those who live on the earth. 11I am coming soon. Hold on to what you have, so that no one will take your crown. (Rev 3:10-11)

  4. If it does refer to the Great Tribulation at the end of the world, why is the 1st Century Philadelphia church promised to be kept from it? They would be long dead by the time it happened.

  5. If this promise to the 1st century Philadelphia church applies to the church in general, why doesn’t the promise to the church in Smyrna (that they would be tossed in prison) apply to the church in general?


Mathison also points out117 that the Greek used in Rev. 3:10 for "keep [protect from]" is the same as in John 17:15
My prayer is not that you take them out of the world but that you protect them from the evil one. (John 17:15)

Where (John 17:15) it is made explicit that God does not have to remove the church to protect it. The Greek for "take" in John 17:15 is not used in Rev. 3:10.


116 Mathison, Dispensationalism, Rightly Dividing the People of God?, pp. 118-119.
117 Ibid., p. 119.